"hypothetical"  question:

Is it ethical to take a photograph of a person off the web, let's just say it's some everyday person, take the photograph into photoshop, make a few small changes to it, pass it through a filter or two, maybe even add a little hand painting to the photo (emphasis on little), and then pass it off as your original artwork with NO MENTION to the fact it was originally a photograph? In fact saying you painted it? Is this really ethical?

If you take the same circumstances as above except you make it a photograph of a famous person...is it even legal to do this?

I would appreciate people's input on this question

Check out my full gallery at Cliff-Dweller Artworks

No it would be a copyright issue with both

Sandy
An imagination can create wonderful things

SndCastie's Little Haven

Quote - No it would be a copyright issue with both

okay thanks...will send you a PM in next few minutes

Check out my full gallery at Cliff-Dweller Artworks

Ok

Sandy
An imagination can create wonderful things

SndCastie's Little Haven

just sent PM to you...this just seemed really wrong to me...let me know if you need more info

Check out my full gallery at Cliff-Dweller Artworks

got it sent you a reply :O)

Sandy
An imagination can create wonderful things

SndCastie's Little Haven

Awwwwwwwwwwwwwww come onnnnnnnnn... you can't bait the hook like that and leave us hanging lol.

lemur01 wrote:

Quote - Awwwwwwwwwwwwwww come onnnnnnnnn... you can't bait the hook like that and leave us hanging lol.

:b_grin: Sorry 'bout that...hehehe...

seriously though, I wasn't sure if what I described above was okay or not...I didn't think it was, but well, so much has changed around here I thought maybe that had changed, too. Once I got the "thumbs down" from an admin, I thought I'd give them a chance to investigate it discretely...

I hope the admins will deal with the situation...I am hopeful that they will...but I do plan to monitor this, so you may hear more if it goes unresolved...

:b_lipssealed: ...for now

Check out my full gallery at Cliff-Dweller Artworks

Hi Cliff-Dweller

This has been brought to the attention of the staff and is now being investigated, and will be resolved as soon as possible.. Thanks for your patience

~Jani

Renderosity Community Admin
---------------------------------------

there were a few of those photomanips in the gallery, the last time I checked. I assume the reason they're allowed is that the actual copyright holders are unaware of them, hence they haven't brought it to yer attention. it probably belongs in a copyright forum with an actual copyright lawyer to tell us, but to post such a photomanip, the manipulator would need both a model release from the subject of the photo, as well as copy permission from whomever owns the original photo, IMVHO.

As stated we are in the process of investigating these and will deal with them.

Sandy
An imagination can create wonderful things

SndCastie's Little Haven

jump & SndCastie...not sure if your comments were directed towards me  ..but, if they were for me, I'm obviously aware that you are investigating this and I have every intention of giving you the time to do so appropriately...don't think I've suggested otherwise.

While any copyright issues are obviously important, my greater concern is frankly that of artistic integrity...if we've lost that, the galleries just become meaningless...

btw, if you weren't talking to me with your posts, then......I'm just waving "hi" :lol:

Check out my full gallery at Cliff-Dweller Artworks

LoL! Yes, I was just letting you know we were on it now

waves 'Hi' back :lol:

~Jani

Renderosity Community Admin
---------------------------------------

LOL no not directed at you :O) Just letting everyone know we are working on it :O)

Sandy
An imagination can create wonderful things

SndCastie's Little Haven