jschoen opened this issue on Apr 09, 2001 ยท 11 posts
jschoen posted Mon, 09 April 2001 at 2:07 PM
Deimos posted Mon, 09 April 2001 at 2:40 PM
Well done. Best of luck.
KateTheShrew posted Mon, 09 April 2001 at 2:54 PM
I've been using FloorPlan since v.4 and it's been a nightmare to get anything out. I did finally figure out how to get the dxf exported so that it can be cleaned up in Max 2.5, but man, it's a hassle. Gotta do one room at a time and color each element differently (baseboards, walls, windows, doors, frames, floor, etc, etc,) otherwise it comes in as one lump and you have to go through the process of splitting it all up. Yuck. Glad to hear that TurboCad outputs in 3ds. I hope it's less of a pain in the neck than the dxf from FloorPlan is. :) Kate P.S. I like the versatility of Punch! over FloorPlan, but the export leaves much to be desired. sigh
jschoen posted Tue, 10 April 2001 at 6:03 AM
There is no export as I can see in Punch, unless you know something I don't? Please share if you do. Some careful planning (pardon the pun) in FloorPlan and a quick run through TurboCad is going well. Just have to make sure you group with colors in the materials requester in FP. This finally got the windows (glass) to export as a different entity then clumped with the rest of the window. It's a little time consuming but in the end I think it will be worth it. James
KateTheShrew posted Tue, 10 April 2001 at 9:24 AM
<< There is no export as I can see in Punch >> Exactly. Leaves much to be desired. ;-) And you're right about the worth of the FP/TurboCad export. It is time consuming, but once you're finished you've got an excellent model. So far I've only done one full building but I've done several individual rooms to use for various projects and they've turned out wonderfully. Kate
jschoen posted Tue, 10 April 2001 at 9:33 AM
Well I've written (emailed) Punch in hopes that maybe they will either make an export available or may know of a plugin or workaround. It does have a 2D DXF export, so how hard could it be to write a 3D export. But still all in all 40 bucks for the pro version wasn't too bad for an almost throw away program. I still like the ease it makes of Decks and would love to have that to create some for my figures to play on. But also has terrible selection of windows, but better fitting than FloorPlan. JEEZ, I wish these companies would make their products complimentary to each other. But I guess that's like asking Steve Jobs and Bill Gates to the same party. ;-) I'm also going to look into Broderbunds Home design software. Seiarra Home design clearly does not work with any CAD or any other program for that matter (as an email i got from them), so It is useless. Well again, I hope to have some freebies and then some saleable items up shortly. James
jschoen posted Tue, 10 April 2001 at 9:43 AM
KateTheShrew posted Tue, 10 April 2001 at 3:49 PM
It looks great, James! I got started with the Broderbund programs. The Home Interiors is only useful if you've got one of those Photo Modeling programs (like Canoma) but it puts out gorgeous rendered images. Sadly, you can't import anything other than jpg or bmp (I have to look it up, it's been so long since I've used it). I will say that they have a marvelous collection of windows, doors, furniture and textures - my gawd, the textures!!! The 3D Architect didn't export in 3D, which is why I went with FloorPlan. Sierra is ok. It does export into 3d dxf format, BUT you can't group by color, etc. When you bring it into a modeling program it's just one mesh, you have to chop it up yourself, which can be a real pain the the nether regions if it's a large, complex model. Word of advice - avoid the Bob Vila software, it's useless. Kate (the Home Improvement Software Junkie)
KateTheShrew posted Tue, 10 April 2001 at 4:10 PM
jschoen posted Wed, 11 April 2001 at 2:22 PM
KateTheShrew posted Thu, 12 April 2001 at 1:24 AM
Oh it makes total sense. I've been grouping by color since I began using floorplan. I just found it easier to work with once it was exported. Kate