Iv been away from Renderosity for some time. 
I just started posting again, and was surfing the renders from Div 3d programs,
browsing the beginner section i saw allot of people giving  tons of credits for work that
was realy badly done.
I know, they are new and need some moraly support. but people was saying "this and that" was "great", when it clearly is not. its like your first try at 3ds, and u place a box. render. and there u go. a MASTERPIECE.
I tought most people in here had some sense of art skills (or what to call it)
Most of the programs i/we use here are realy hard to learn. schooling and nights on end working with our models/landskapes.

i think its about time people start giving out the hard facts when a beginner post someting.
its not to be hard on him.. but to help him/her along the path.

When a post say Critical and non-critical. they want our opinion. and its unfair to them if they render a box in clay. and we say "WOW" did u make that?!?! forget my 100.000poly tank iv been working of for 3mnds, this box just blows me away!!!

i hope u all understand.

-Seather