Well, just got done watching it. 
And IMO it is on the same level as Unforgiven.
But I am a junkie for this kind of stuff. Yeah, I know it promotes violence, murder and the like...but as an old friend used to say, "There's honor among theives."
Crowe did a great job, not too much, not too little...didn't try to impose his will upon the story but was a part of it, excellent. A really great job by Brolin too.
Really enjoyed it. I sensed what their agreement was toward the end but was still unsure (until the end). Even then Wade was still putting himself out in the line of fire, even got hit.
But as gut level western's go, this was way cool. If you are into this kind of stuff, a definate see.

Comitted to excellence through art.