Raw versus .JPG, why even ask that question since we all know raw is superior…or is it really?   I have a friend who has asked me about using Raw.  His camera came with Photoshop Elements 3 with the basic Adobe raw converter.   He now asks, “I am still a bit fuzzy on why raw is better but am willing to be convinced.”

 

Can you give me ways to convince?  The links here are to articles concerning  Raw versus JPG.  This first link is to an article essentially saying jpg is just as good as raw. The second link gives a few reasons demonstrated by photo of why Raw is better in some circumstances.

 

http://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/raw.htm

 

http://www.ics.uci.edu/~eppstein/pix/rawvsjpg/

 

 

I shoot both Raw and JPG, depending on the situation. Most of the time I shoot Raw, convinced I do get a better final render, especially for print.  I believe Raw provides me with better color depth, better detail in highlights, less color wash in some images and for the fine image is the way to go.   Still, some argue Raw is only for the best shots and is a waste of time otherwise.  Who is correct, anyone?

 

Subjectivity has something to do with it, perhaps.  Perhaps the belief that the image is better in Raw conversion has something to do with believing Raw is better.  Honestly, for some images, I see little difference but for others the differences are apparent and the gold star goes to Raw.

 

Raw conversion software is possibly part of the confusion, assuming Raw is better overall or not so great.   Having used RawShooter, then the initial Adobe converter in CS2, Lightroom and PhaseOne Capture One 4  there are differences in quality from different software.  Capture One appears to me to render better detail and color depth than any of the others.  The converter in CS2 is one I have not found versatile enough after using Lightroom.  RawShooter is gone unless you have the older software before the Adobe buyout.

 

What can you say from personal observation and/or from technical detail to convince that Raw is superior to JPG?   I will appreciate any responses.

 

Thanks,      Tom.