Forum: Photoshop


Subject: 3d texturing in CS5E

Eclipse1024 opened this issue on Dec 09, 2010 · 6 posts


Eclipse1024 posted Thu, 09 December 2010 at 10:28 PM

I just started playing around with the 3d functionality in CS5E and wondered if I might get some suggestions.

The principle activity I'm hoping to use it for is direct texture editing on the OBJ itself.  I've had success exporting (from Poser) the required OBJ along with the MTL file and needed textures.  I also had little problem loading it up in CS5E but here's where my experience hits a sour note.

I'd played briefly with 3d-coat in the spring and, although it doesn't hold a candle to the graphic editing capabilities of photoshop, I found it much better at painting directly on the 3d object.  Unfortunately, 3dc was just a 30day eval and I already own CS5E, so I'm trying to leverage what I have.

Specifically, what I'm trying to do is create new a V4 skin.  With 3dc I was able to load up a portion of the V4 mesh, along with a base texture, then create and new texture to overlay the existing one so my edits weren't applied directly to the base texture.  I can't figure out how to do the same in CS5E.  I can create a new layer but it's just a 2d layer and I have to merge down into the 3d layer in order to apply it, otherwise it just floats there above the object in a 2d plane.  Is there a way to add an additional texture layer to an object so I'm not having to edit the original texture directly?

Also, I'm not too happy with the performance.  Even if I load just a portion of the mesh (like a hand) I find it very clunky to spin the model unless zoomed way out.  Also, in order to preserve the 4x4k texture detail I need to increase the "image size" of the 3d object from the default 1x1k to at least 4x4k or higher.  In doing so the response lag becomes even worse to a point where you can't even think of using anything other than single click actions as it can't track your pen movements (only updating every 1/4 second or so).  3d-Coat didn't seem to have this "image size" issue and I could actually load up the entire mesh all at once, be able to zoom all the way in, and still have it perform smooth as glass.  Is there some other way of increasing the working resolution within Photoshop without having performance suffer so badly?  Or am just trying to use Photoshop for something it's not designed to do?

I'm already comfortable with Photoshop so I'd prefer to use it than have to relearn another package, like 3d-coat or Zbrush, not to mention the added expense.  I just find all the whacky seams in the Daz UV maps difficult to navigate in 2d so I'd really like to explore using direct 3d texture editing to clean up seams and nail down texture placements accurately the first time.

Any suggestions would be most welcome!