jerr3d opened this issue on Jan 10, 2011 · 61 posts
jerr3d posted Mon, 10 January 2011 at 5:27 PM
Maybe it is too late for that since DAZ continues to develop DAZ Studio. But to me the ultimate Poser Pro 2012 would be the Poser app with Vicki 5 /Aiko 5/ Michael 5 pre-installed.
Miss Nancy posted Mon, 10 January 2011 at 7:11 PM
they won't IMVHO. when poser was for sale last time, they bought carrara instead. SM won't let go of it AFAIK.
Tashar59 posted Mon, 10 January 2011 at 8:55 PM
Agree with Miss Nancy that they won't. DAZ has gone in a different direction with different tech that does the same and uses much the same content, differently. To much time and money developing DS and a little of that into Carrara. They don't need Poser. Only the users to sell content to.
Besides the base figures are free or will be free, stated by Daz in a thread. So no real need to have them included. It's the extras you pay for and would still have to pay for if the figures were included in Poser.
alexcoppo posted Mon, 10 January 2011 at 10:58 PM
Given the track record of DAZ w.r.t. program development after having bought them, if they bought Poser I would install MakeHuman :lol:
Bye!!!
GIMP 2.7.4, Inkscape 0.48, Genetica 3.6 Basic, FilterForge 3 Professional, Blender 2.61, SketchUp 8, PoserPro 2012, Vue 10 Infinite, World Machine 2.3, GeoControl 2
Nance posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 12:19 AM
A degree of competition is a good thing. Not keen on the idea of having only one source in the market.
wolf359 posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 4:56 AM
Quote - ** They don't need Poser. Only the users to sell content to.**
Exactly!!!
Cheers
vilters posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 9:17 AM
NO, please NO!
Let there be competition to keep everybody on their toe"s.
Poser 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7,
P8 and PPro2010, P9 and PP2012, P10 and PP2014 Game
Dev
"Do not drive
faster then your angel can fly"!
MatCreator posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 9:39 AM
Please don't say such things.................................................................
For Daz to own the Poserverse, would be "not good" =/
There are 3 kinds of people in the
world. Those that can count, and those that can't..
MatCreator posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 9:42 AM
Even further, they should sell off their other software to Smith Micro... Let them focus on Daz Studio and content, they can't handle more than that =|
There are 3 kinds of people in the
world. Those that can count, and those that can't..
Disciple3d posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 10:35 AM
Daz does content best IMHO! Though one upside to them owning software is a cheap price tag for a PC members. Look at the price the most recent version of Bryce used to bring versus what it cost to get the latest greatest version today. That price went down sharply when Daz purchased it. Same with Carrarra if I'm not mistaken, which admittedly, I could be.
If you want to up your content game, get schooled to be a pro with Sixus1 Mentoring today!
LaurieA posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 11:10 AM
Here's one hoping Daz sells Hexagon to someone who will actually UPDATE the damn thing ;o). Seems they've lost complete interest in it over Carrara which is sad, very sad. Some folks just want a modeler not a monster ;o). I'm so ready to move on to Silo...lol.
Laurie
MagnusGreel posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 11:15 AM
with Hex it's simply it does not fit their sales model.
with DS, Bryce, Carrara, they can sell you content. Hex is all about making things, not content, so once they sell you a copy, thats it. no more money coming in, bye bye. not what Daz's sales model wants....
Airport security is a burden we must all shoulder. Do your part, and please grope yourself in advance.
edgeverse posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 6:16 PM
I don't think Daz will buy Poser. It's just something I cannot see.
3D Digital Comics & Art/My homepage
http://www.edgeversemedia.com
MatCreator posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 6:44 PM
"Daz" doesn't make content, the artists that broker w/ it do all the content creating, and most of them sell here as well...
If Daz3d were to focus on just Daz Studio and the content end of things, it would be much better for everyone, they put too much effort into the other things that, as mentioned and I agree, doesn't fit their "sales model"...
If Smith Micro picked up Carrara, Bryce and Hex, that'd be too awesome... They CAN handle software, and having all the family in one place again would be golden. It should have been the logical path, but that's just me...
Daz can push content for their figures, and the software we render in is pretty much a moot issue, but for those that can't handle the big guns (was that a tomato someone threw?!?), they have the option of Daz Studio, only ensuring -anyone- can take advantage of their content... They have a free version, and should someone choose, an advanced version. Pretty slick actually...
They sell Hex for 2 dollars, you can't expect any development on that, it may as well be free. If you did the math, ALL sales on Hex prolly isn't worth even 1 1/2 descent software engineer =/ They also gave Carrara away w/ a magazine not too long ago... That really doesn't push content, and was NOT necessary, as people can use and render w/ the free Daz Studio. It only gave them another rendering option. Bryce was free for quite a while, and the newest release isn't expensive at all. I just don't think any of their software they are running is worth it "to them"... It makes a very small percentage of what they bring in...
::: check me out, all in the biznizz :::
In short, they really aren't doing anything w/ the software they have now anyways. Sell it off, and focus on Daz Studio and Content.
There are 3 kinds of people in the
world. Those that can count, and those that can't..
Boni posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 6:46 PM
Hmmm. I think the question is theoretical. What IF Daz baught Poser. What would change ... what would Poser look like, do . .. etc. That's how I read it.
Boni
"Be Hero to Yourself" -- Peter Tork
ksanderson posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 7:56 PM
Quote - In short, they really aren't doing anything w/ the software they have now anyways. Sell it off, and focus on Daz Studio and Content.
I have to disagree. They've updated Carrara to 64 bit, added bullet physics, IES lights, improved NLA, added Puppeteer and multitudes of bug fixes. Remember, when they bought it, Carrara had lots of bugs. Yes, they could do more, but at the price they charge (which is very low if you buy it on sale) they are doing great. Imagine what it would cost if they hired more developers. We'd have to pay for it. They've also breathed new life into Bryce, where it can now really turn out landscapes and skies you had to go to Vue to come close to get, though it still has room to improve, too. But it's still much more affordable. I still think Hex could be brought back, and maybe they have a plan to do that eventually. But with all the other modelers out there and especially with modo and Z-brush so popular, what could they really do?
It's funny to me that people now think Smith Micro would take care of the software DAZ now owns. I remember the comments when they took over Poser and it was like the end of the world was near. So much idiotic comment posting... but that's almost expected anymore these days. :(
ElZagna posted Tue, 11 January 2011 at 10:55 PM
What I think I'd like to see is Poser bought out by Adobe and integrated into their tool suite. In that scenario, Adobe would probably just buy the underlying 3d technology and redesign the interface to be more compatible with their other tools, and let's hope more user friendly. The problem for Adobe in this case might be that the whole buyinig and selling of content is not compatible with their business model.
OS: Windows 10 64-bit, Poser: 10
EClark1894 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 12:09 AM
Quote - Agree with Miss Nancy that they won't. DAZ has gone in a different direction with different tech that does the same and uses much the same content, differently. To much time and money developing DS and a little of that into Carrara. They don't need Poser. Only the users to sell content to.
Besides the base figures are free or will be free, stated by Daz in a thread. So no real need to have them included. It's the extras you pay for and would still have to pay for if the figures were included in Poser.
Actually, to say they don't need Poser is somewhat misleading. A LOT of people still use Poser, even though D/S is pretty much either free or at least cheaper. Granted, they have the most popular figure in the Poserverse, but it's not the ONLY figure in the Poserverse, nor is DAZ the only place you can buy or sell figures and models for Poser.
So really, Poser doesn't need DAZ as much as DAZ needs Poser.
MatCreator posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 1:29 AM
Yeah, admittedly, they've improved Carrara, but no matter how great it gets, it does nothing to help push their content. Most do NOT model w/ it, and even for all it's animation power, Vue is what you hear about w/ regards to Hollywood... Carrara is my favorite program btw, but lets be real... Hex has been abandoned... Another of my favorite apps, but abandoned nonetheless. The Bryce overhaul was long overdue... Again, I see no need to focus on it, its a very trimmed down Carrara. Is it really worth the effort when you compare its price tag, when your point is to sell content? I don't think so =/
I think people "know" Smith Micro can take care of the software Daz owns because Smith Micro is a software company whereas Daz (and even they will say it til they are blue in the face) is a content for Poser/Daz Studio company. They have differnt mind sets... Daz would be Daz w/o any of the programs. We go there for the figures and other stuff.
Smith Micro is only one choice... Me personally, I'd have liked for Adobe to snatch up or incorporate Metacreations when that time came, then the family would all be togther in the best of hands... If you think about it, Adobe doesn't sell filters, plug-ins, brushes, or other valuable presets that can be used even w/ PhotoShop, ad they don't need to, other places are set up just for that... People still use Xenofex, Eyecandy and KPT's...
There are 3 kinds of people in the
world. Those that can count, and those that can't..
RorrKonn posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 1:39 AM
I will never get why thay made D/S to work just like Poser.
Poser ,D/S is 10 times more difficult to use than it needs to be.
============================================================
The
Artist that will fight for decades to conquer their media.
Even if you never know their name ,your know their Art.
Dark Sphere Mage Vengeance
Tashar59 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 1:51 AM
Quote - Actually, to say they don't need Poser is somewhat misleading. A LOT of people still use Poser, even though D/S is pretty much either free or at least cheaper. Granted, they have the most popular figure in the Poserverse, but it's not the ONLY figure in the Poserverse, nor is DAZ the only place you can buy or sell figures and models for Poser. So really, Poser doesn't need DAZ as much as DAZ needs Poser.
No, you are reading something into my post that I did not say. I said Daz does not need to buy Poser. They already have two apps that basically do the same thing. I also said they do need the Poser user. To SELL content to.
We don't need adobe to buy anything. Then only the well off or warez users will have it. Just like photoshop is now.
Tashar59 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 2:02 AM
Quote - I will never get why thay made D/S to work just like Poser.
Poser ,D/S is 10 times more difficult to use than it needs to be.
That seems to be changing. It was stated today that the V5 figures are LOD. That means not only would Poser have to develope the wieghtmap rigging but also the SubD as DS to take full advantage of the new figures. It is the same as V4 in that regard. V4 is LOD in DS only.
I think the OP has a major flaw. But only SM and DAZ can say for sure and they are not saying anything. Except DAZ showing us V5 for DS. She does look good.
alexcoppo posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 2:15 AM
A word about Studio being free: Studio base is free but even the most trivial task requires plugins which are in most cases commercial. Just adding a new morph thru an OBJ file requires a plugin.
When I was thinking of gettting Poser I did a check of how much it would cost to replicate the functionality and I discovered how much Studio does actually cost.
Morph target thru OBJ file: Morph Loader (10$)
Rigging:Figure Setup Tools (30$)
Dynamic Clothes: Dynamic Clothing Control (50$)
I bought Poser 8 for 104$ during the last Smith Micro sale and the above list amounts, just by itself, to 90$. Remember also that Poser can drape any "cloth" while Studio can only handle specific (and not cheap) content.
If I add to the equation a program like Blender or Wings3D we also have:
Decimator for DAZ Studio (100$)
Reality (80$)
mgHeightfield Primitives for DS3 (15$) and
FBX Plug-in for DAZ Studio (100$)
for a total of 295$.
Our "free" as beer program now costs 385$. Poser 8 without sales is 250$ so, we are left with 135$. If we add 64 additional dollars, we can also add Vue 9 Esprit (again not sale) to the bundle.
Still thinking that Studio is so great?
GIMP 2.7.4, Inkscape 0.48, Genetica 3.6 Basic, FilterForge 3 Professional, Blender 2.61, SketchUp 8, PoserPro 2012, Vue 10 Infinite, World Machine 2.3, GeoControl 2
EClark1894 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 5:29 AM
Quote - > Quote - Actually, to say they don't need Poser is somewhat misleading. A LOT of people still use Poser, even though D/S is pretty much either free or at least cheaper. Granted, they have the most popular figure in the Poserverse, but it's not the ONLY figure in the Poserverse, nor is DAZ the only place you can buy or sell figures and models for Poser. So really, Poser doesn't need DAZ as much as DAZ needs Poser.
No, you are reading something into my post that I did not say. I said Daz does not need to buy Poser. They already have two apps that basically do the same thing. I also said they do need the Poser user. To SELL content to.
We don't need adobe to buy anything. Then only the well off or warez users will have it. Just like photoshop is now.
Sorry for the misunderstanding. It was the way you worded your post.
You know, interestingly enough, when I first bought Poser (2) all those years ago, it was years before I finally bought something from DAZ. I mainly used the Poser characters and clothes that came with Poser. In fact, it wasn't until I bought Poser 4 that I finally started to download even freebies from places like Fairyworld, and Poserworld.
jerr3d posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 7:42 AM
So if the two companys/apps are not going to merge, will they go their own ways, developing proprietary figures, or maintain a shaky alliance which benefits both companys and all users of both softwares?
LaurieA posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 8:01 AM
Quote - So if the two companys/apps are not going to merge, will they go their own ways, developing proprietary figures, or maintain a shaky alliance which benefits both companys and all users of both softwares?
I think that about sums it up ;o).
I used to think that perhaps Daz would abandon Poser users in favor of their own software and leave us in the dust, but that would really be a bad business move. Not that they're above that sort of thing tho...lol.
Laurie
wolf359 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 8:06 AM
"If I add to the equation a program like Blender or Wings3D we also have:
Decimator for DAZ Studio (100$)
Reality (80$)
mgHeightfield Primitives for DS3 (15$) and
FBX Plug-in for DAZ Studio (100$)
for a total of 295$.
Our "free" as beer program now costs 385$. Poser 8 without sales is 250$ so, we are left with 135$. If we add 64 additional dollars, we can also add Vue 9 Esprit (again not sale) to the bundle.
Still thinking that Studio is so great?"
Hi no offense but I read such
"true cost of DS" ,break downs Like this all the time in these DS vs poser discussions
and yours is just as arbitrary and self serving as all of the others I have read.
BTW You "forgot " to Add $2500-$3000 for a copy of Autodesk MAX ,Maya or Maxon C4D to receive FBX exports from Daz studio.
You assume (Falsely) that the average Daz user literallyNEEDS
all the additional Items you listed to produce a viable Still render.
well one visit to the DAZ galleries clearly proves that they do not.
Most DS users are more than happy with the free version
plus maybe the reality plugin ($80 USD) for the "well heeled"
and the cost of Content is not relevant to the discussion
because both DS& poser users will need to buy additional Content after all the galleries here are not exactly flooded with renders of
"Alyson"& "Ryan" are they?? .
Cheers
MagnusGreel posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 8:08 AM
"BTW You "forgot " to Add $2500-$3000 for a copy of Autodesk MAX ,Maya or Maxon C4D to receive FBX exports from Daz studio."
Wings3d supports FBX Import/Export cough cost, $0.
Airport security is a burden we must all shoulder. Do your part, and please grope yourself in advance.
wolf359 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 8:18 AM
"Wings3d supports FBX Import/Export cough cost, $0."
Correct sir, but that Does help NOT promote the Agenda of convincing others how "Expensive" the Free version of DS allegedly is.
I mean Why mention the $100 third party FBX export plugin when colladda Export( Supported by the aformentioned pro apps) Comes FREE with all versions of Daz studio.
Cheers
LaurieA posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 9:11 AM
I'm gonna take a page from pjz99's book...lol. I think it's time ;o).
Laurie
jerr3d posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 9:26 AM
Quote - > Quote - So if the two companys/apps are not going to merge, will they go their own ways, developing proprietary figures, or maintain a shaky alliance which benefits both companys and all users of both softwares?
I think that about sums it up ;o).
I used to think that perhaps Daz would abandon Poser users in favor of their own software and leave us in the dust, but that would really be a bad business move. Not that they're above that sort of thing tho...lol.
Laurie
I at least hope this WILL BE the case, but isn't Miki3 equipped with a custom rigging system made for POSER 8 and Pro 2010 only? And as was mentioned earlier "It was stated today that the V5 figures are LOD. That means not only would Poser have to develope the wieghtmap rigging but also the SubD as DS to take full advantage of the new figures. It is the same as V4 in that regard. V4 is LOD in DS only."
So are these two new developments healthy competition or a sign that the two companies are slowly moving in exclusive directions ?
EClark1894 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 9:27 AM
Quote - "If I add to the equation a program like Blender or Wings3D we also have:
Decimator for DAZ Studio (100$) Reality (80$) mgHeightfield Primitives for DS3 (15$) and FBX Plug-in for DAZ Studio (100$)
for a total of 295$.
Our "free" as beer program now costs 385$. Poser 8 without sales is 250$ so, we are left with 135$. If we add 64 additional dollars, we can also add Vue 9 Esprit (again not sale) to the bundle.
Still thinking that Studio is so great?"Hi no offense but I read such
"true cost of DS" ,break downs Like this all the time in these DS vs poser discussions
and yours is just as arbitrary and self serving as all of the others I have read.BTW You "forgot " to Add $2500-$3000 for a copy of Autodesk MAX ,Maya or Maxon C4D to receive FBX exports from Daz studio.
You assume (Falsely) that the average Daz user literallyNEEDS
all the additional Items you listed to produce a viable Still render.
well one visit to the DAZ galleries clearly proves that they do not.
Most DS users are more than happy with the free version
plus maybe the reality plugin ($80 USD) for the "well heeled"
and the cost of Content is not relevant to the discussion
because both DS& poser users will need to buy additional Content after all the galleries here are not exactly flooded with renders of
"Alyson"& "Ryan" are they?? .Cheers
Big deal. There's not a whole lot of renders of Stephanie 3 here either. What's your point Wolf? Because frankly, there's a whole lot of freebies out there where DAZ wouldn't make a cent off of.
lmckenzie posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 9:54 AM
"Democracy is a pathetic belief in the collective wisdom of individual ignorance." - H. L. Mencken
wolf359 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 9:55 AM
Quote -
Big deal. There's not a whole lot of renders of Stephanie 3 here either. What's your point Wolf?
My point is that most people are buying third party content anyway
so it is not really valid and frankly Misleading to try and pad the cost of the base program
by adding in the cost of such OPTIONAL but not required third party content
it is a phoney ,straw man argument for a D/S user to say:
"poser 8 really $$cost$$ this much because
you have to buy such & such to replace that horrible Ryan and Alyson"
Just as it is a straw man argument to say the DAZ base is not really FREE because You have to get the "Decimator" plugin.
Cheers
alexcoppo posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 11:26 AM
Scenario: carmaker A sells you a car ready to roll out of the showroom while carmaker B lists, among the optionals, the steering wheel (yes, it is an optional; just get a wrench and turn the control rod by hand. Maybe it is not easy but can be done and in most cases roads are straight so turning is not a frequent requirement, right?)
Don't everybody think that it might be "reasonable", when comparing the price of the two options, to add to B base cost all the optionals required to bring car B on pair with car A? Or I am too convoluted? Hard question. Add Rodin's Thinker image here.
GIMP 2.7.4, Inkscape 0.48, Genetica 3.6 Basic, FilterForge 3 Professional, Blender 2.61, SketchUp 8, PoserPro 2012, Vue 10 Infinite, World Machine 2.3, GeoControl 2
wolf359 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 11:49 AM
Quote -
Don't everybody think that it might be "reasonable", when comparing the price of the two options, to add to B base cost all the optionals required to bring car B on pair with car A?
Yes but be intellectually honest and state that your desire for optional add ons or poser style features
will make the usage cost X dollar amount higher for you.
Dont accuse the maker of a base no frills version of misrepresenting the "real" price
which frankly is just what people intend do when they claim Daz studio is "not really" FREE.
You can get the FREE Daz studio
get the FREE Vic/Mic Clones
scour the various user communities for FREE textures,props Clothing sets,
or Use the Afformentioned Wings 3D& Gimp.blender etc etc. and create your own Content.
If you dont believe this is possible just visit the Daz Forums,freepository and galleries and see what is being created& rendered at no cost beyond hardware & time spent
which is a GOOD thing in this economy IMHO
This attempted trick of arbitrarily Picking, expensive ,optional third party DS add ons and trying to convince people that they represent the true cost of Daz studio does not fool anyone and only Exposes the claimants anti-Daz agenda.
and your Car example is rather silly as a car with no usable steering Equipment can not be considerd a usable vehicle by any sane standard
a Free 3D figure posing and rendering program with no Dynamic cloth or FBX plugin included for free can still meet a certain useable standard and functionality just as poser did for many years before getting such features.
cheers
LaurieA posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 12:28 PM
While I agree with most of what you said wolf359, I think what ppl are getting at is that to compare DS and Poser apples to apples, some money needs to be spent on DS, that's all ;o). But of course it can be used as-is with the free version.
Laurie
wolf359 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 1:14 PM
Quote - I think what ppl are getting at is that to compare DS and Poser apples to apples, some money needs to be spent on DS,
Laurie
Agreed Laurie
but people should consider that not every D/S user is a former poser user wedded to having his former functionality
many over their are stereo typical > CLICK/LOAD & RENDER users
this notion of :
"to get up to the functionality of poser you must buy..blah blah." is a Poser users concern
the "Lifelong" DS user simply does not care about what poser can do
nor should he care as long as he can render his premade figures morphs, props lights etc to his/her satisfaction.
Cheers
Tashar59 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 1:40 PM
Quote - but isn't Miki3 equipped with a custom rigging system made for POSER 8 and Pro 2010 only? And as was mentioned earlier "It was stated today that the V5 figures are LOD. That means not only would Poser have to develope the wieghtmap rigging but also the SubD as DS to take full advantage of the new figures. It is the same as V4 in that regard. V4 is LOD in DS only."So are these two new developments healthy competition or a sign that the two companies are slowly moving in exclusive directions ?
Yes and no. IMO. Like V4, Daz will sell V5 that should work with Poser. They say they are working with other software companies. So you can assume that SM is one. That's half of DAZ's clients and it would hurt them if Poser users had to drop Daz's new figures. That would mean less money for development of thier own software. But you can't blame DAZ for not moving forward and leaving Poser behind if Poser can't keep up with the new tech
Miki 3 is a bad example. Very disappointing. Yes the rigging is a bit better but not much and those shoulders and chest side caving is atrocious. The DS users that complain about Miki 3 being P8/PP2010 only are just complaining and it also gives them ammo to throw in Poser users face when talking about the new DAZ figures/content may not work well in Poser. Bad for everyone. Lets face it, we have been spoiled with DAZ figures and if you can't make a figure comparable to thiers and only works for the latest version on one brand. You have lost the race.
I do think in time DAZ will have to leave Poser to continue on the development path they have chosen. I don't think that will be for some time, but will eventually happen.
dphoadley posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 3:37 PM
dph
LaurieA posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 3:48 PM
Quote - I still prefer Posette! Remapped PosetteV3 with Nanette Tredoux custom made hair, the Nelly Bly Coat Freebie, and my own Custom made hat (Done in Max). The pose is one that i'm working on for her to grasp the steering Wheel of a ship.
dph
Uh....posted in the wrong thread?
Laurie
dphoadley posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 3:53 PM
No, just showing that I have and like Poser Pro 2010, and especially since its IDL makes my beloved Posette shine all the brighter!!! And as far as content is concerned, I'm making a lot of my own nowadays!!
dph
RorrKonn posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 4:59 PM
Quote - > Quote - I will never get why thay made D/S to work just like Poser.
Poser ,D/S is 10 times more difficult to use than it needs to be.
That seems to be changing. It was stated today that the V5 figures are LOD. That means not only would Poser have to develope the wieghtmap rigging but also the SubD as DS to take full advantage of the new figures. It is the same as V4 in that regard. V4 is LOD in DS only.
I think the OP has a major flaw. But only SM and DAZ can say for sure and they are not saying anything. Except DAZ showing us V5 for DS. She does look good.
Got a link to the V5 ?
Drives me insain to try to work on a 60,000 poly count mesh
============================================================
The
Artist that will fight for decades to conquer their media.
Even if you never know their name ,your know their Art.
Dark Sphere Mage Vengeance
Tashar59 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 5:38 PM
Attached Link: V5
> Quote - > Quote - > Quote - I will never get why thay made D/S to work just like Poser. > > > > > > Poser ,D/S is 10 times more difficult to use than it needs to be. > > > > That seems to be changing. It was stated today that the V5 figures are LOD. That means not only would Poser have to develope the wieghtmap rigging but also the SubD as DS to take full advantage of the new figures. It is the same as V4 in that regard. V4 is LOD in DS only. > > > > I think the OP has a major flaw. But only SM and DAZ can say for sure and they are not saying anything. Except DAZ showing us V5 for DS. She does look good. > > Got a link to the V5 ? > > Drives me insain to try to work on a 60,000 poly count mesh > >
click on the V5. Page 43 shows her but there are a couple of other images through the whole thread that also show how her joints look posed as in hand and shoulders.
EClark1894 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 7:22 PM
Quote - > Quote - but isn't Miki3 equipped with a custom rigging system made for POSER 8 and Pro 2010 only? And as was mentioned earlier "It was stated today that the V5 figures are LOD. That means not only would Poser have to develope the wieghtmap rigging but also the SubD as DS to take full advantage of the new figures. It is the same as V4 in that regard. V4 is LOD in DS only."So are these two new developments healthy competition or a sign that the two companies are slowly moving in exclusive directions ?
Yes and no. IMO. Like V4, Daz will sell V5 that should work with Poser. They say they are working with other software companies. So you can assume that SM is one. That's half of DAZ's clients and it would hurt them if Poser users had to drop Daz's new figures. That would mean less money for development of thier own software. But you can't blame DAZ for not moving forward and leaving Poser behind if Poser can't keep up with the new tech
Miki 3 is a bad example. Very disappointing. Yes the rigging is a bit better but not much and those shoulders and chest side caving is atrocious. The DS users that complain about Miki 3 being P8/PP2010 only are just complaining and it also gives them ammo to throw in Poser users face when talking about the new DAZ figures/content may not work well in Poser. Bad for everyone. Lets face it, we have been spoiled with DAZ figures and if you can't make a figure comparable to thiers and only works for the latest version on one brand. You have lost the race.
I do think in time DAZ will have to leave Poser to continue on the development path they have chosen. I don't think that will be for some time, but will eventually happen.
Well, it still remains to be seen if D/S4 will adopt Poser's new rigging. Of course, unlike DAZ Poser doesn't really push it's figures, so DAZ actually has the upper hand when it comes to determining what will and won't work with D/S. Poser, on the other hand, is DAZ's bitch in that regard.
Tashar59 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 8:27 PM
Quote - Well, it still remains to be seen if D/S4 will adopt Poser's new rigging.
Why would they? They might but why. For one poor, rigged figure? They are better off sticking with thier new flagship tech and make Poser conform. If people want better figures they will learn to adapt by either finding a way to use them in Poser or migrate to DS or deal with what they have. It's obvious after Miki 3 that they don't have any competition in figures.
Before anyone freaks. Antonia is a great figure but not competition to DAZ.
wolf359 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 9:06 PM
Quote - Why would they? They might but why. For one poor, rigged figure? They are better off sticking with thier new flagship tech and make Poser conform
Agreed I assume everyone has already seen THIS
also It has been hinted By Bagginsbill that there is new revolutionary figure tech coming from SM as well so big changes ahead for all.
Cheers
coldrake posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 9:42 PM
alexcoppo wrote;> Quote - A word about Studio being free: Studio base is free but even the most trivial task requires plugins which are in most cases commercial.
The most trivial task requires plugins? That statment is simply ridiculous.
alexcoppo wrote;
Quote - When I was thinking of gettting Poser I did a check of how much it would cost to replicate the functionality and I discovered how much Studio does actually cost.
Morph target thru OBJ file: Morph Loader (10$)
It cost me $1.99
alexcoppo wrote;
Quote - Rigging:Figure Setup Tools (30$)
It cost me $14.68** **
alexcoppo wrote;
Quote - Dynamic Clothes: Dynamic Clothing Control (50$)
It cost me $17.49
alexcoppo wrote;
Quote - I bought Poser 8 for 104$ during the last Smith Micro sale and the above list amounts, just by itself, to 90$.
As long as you are talking about sales, I got the above for $34.16 That's a whopping $69.84 less than you paid for Poser 8.
Even if I add in what I paid for DAZ Studio 3 Advanced, $52.49, the total comes to $86.65. That's still $17.35 less than you paid for Poser 8.
alexcoppo wrote;
Quote - Remember also that Poser can drape any "cloth" while Studio can only handle specific (and not cheap) content.
Actually Poser dynamic clothing here in the Market place is priced about the same as dynamic clothing for DAZ Studio.
** **alexcoppo wrote;
Quote - Still thinking that Studio is so great?
Absolutely!
My entire point is that you can bandy about numbers and features until it's pointless.
The fact is Poser has features that DAZ Studio doesn't, and DAZ Studio has features that Poser doesn't. They are on about equal ground, which one you choose depends which feels more comfortable, if you want features the other doesn't have or any other number of reasons. Not because one is better than the other.
I thought we were all past the "my program is better than your program" thing. Guess not. :rolleyes: Can't we all just get along? :biggrin:
I've been using Poser since Poser 3 and I still love it, though I will admit the only reason I have Poser 7 is for using the cloth room to make morph targets for import into DAZ Studio, and because Bloodsong's Heavy Horse for some reason doesn't work in DAZ Studio. The main reason I use DAZ Studio instead of Poser is workflow. The gui just works better for me. Simple.
RorrKonn, if I remember correctly, the polycount is either 17,000 or 19,000.
Coldrake
Tashar59 posted Wed, 12 January 2011 at 9:46 PM
Quote - also It has been hinted By Bagginsbill that there is new revolutionary figure tech coming from SM as well so big changes ahead for all.Cheers
Or was it just a hint that SM will be adding wieghtmap rigging to use DAZ figures. Or I missed a different hint by BB in a different thread.
Cage posted Thu, 13 January 2011 at 12:24 AM
Quote - Agreed I assume everyone has already seen THIS
I hadn't seen that. Pretty cool, really. Thank you! :D
===========================sigline======================================================
Cage can be an opinionated jerk who posts without thinking. He apologizes for this. He's honestly not trying to be a turkeyhead.
Cage had some freebies, compatible with Poser 11 and below. His Python scripts were saved at archive.org, along with the rest of the Morphography site, where they were hosted.
RorrKonn posted Thu, 13 January 2011 at 12:40 AM
The only reson Poser is still around after be boult n sold more times then I can count and D/S even exist is The 99% Hobbyist that buy the merchandise is the only reson that Poser or D/S even exist
The out dated 1902 Poser and D/S are both worthless with out a stocked runtime.
Most the time I could not tell you if it's a Poser or D/S Render.
And thank the Gods of Art that the Poser D/S Merchants are very very kool.
Thay make us look good don't thay.
http://www.turbosquid.com/ Real Scary Place.
============================================================
The
Artist that will fight for decades to conquer their media.
Even if you never know their name ,your know their Art.
Dark Sphere Mage Vengeance
derrys1969 posted Sun, 23 January 2011 at 11:44 AM
Ah, this debate will never end...stop fussing and make art...LOL!
aeilkema posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 7:28 AM
DAZ taking over Poser...... that would be great! Seriously, because if DAZ does we will at least see some real development again, instead of all these flashy gimmicks. They should just combine the 2 apps into one well working application. Smith Micro should donate all of the Poser code to DAZ, as a little thank you, since it's because of DAZ that Poser is still around.
Artwork and 3DToons items, create the perfect place for you toon and other figures!
http://www.renderosity.com/mod/bcs/index.php?vendor=23722
Due to the childish TOS changes, I'm not allowed to link to my other products outside of Rendo anymore :(
Food for thought.....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYZw0dfLmLk
MagnusGreel posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 7:38 AM
and I thought you were giving up 3D totally aeilkema? so what's it matter to you?
Airport security is a burden we must all shoulder. Do your part, and please grope yourself in advance.
aeilkema posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 7:53 AM
Quote - and I thought you were giving up 3D totally aeilkema? so what's it matter to you?
Give up 3D??? You mean I can't play games anymore on my recently purchased XBox that I was able to buy because of selling a lot of 3D assets I don't use anymore?
Artwork and 3DToons items, create the perfect place for you toon and other figures!
http://www.renderosity.com/mod/bcs/index.php?vendor=23722
Due to the childish TOS changes, I'm not allowed to link to my other products outside of Rendo anymore :(
Food for thought.....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pYZw0dfLmLk
MagnusGreel posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 8:18 AM
....right. I was warned... he argues everything without fail.. silly of me.... shuts up
* *
Airport security is a burden we must all shoulder. Do your part, and please grope yourself in advance.
LaurieA posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 8:44 AM
If Daz took over Poser we'd have real development? You're kidding right? Daz isn't a large company. It's a small office in Utah. Get real.
One thing everyone needs to remember is that Smith Micro actually has the money to invest in this little niche program we all love and hate...hehe. Daz has an awful tendency to buy a program and let it just sit....or release a new one with a mediocre upgrade. I'm not talking about DS now...I'm talking about programs they bought, like Bryce and Hexagon. Hexagon is for the most part dead and a new version of Bryce took quite a while as I remember. There's nothing at all wrong with the speed at which SM has been releasing Poser or the speed at which they've been adding new features.
Laurie
jerr3d posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 9:31 AM
Anyone who takes an interest in Poser is eventually going to have to move on to the DAZ figures, since they are better than those included with Poser.
But isn't this kinda' like buying a car from Ford and then taking it to Toyota to put in the air conditioner because Toyota makes better a/c units ?!
LaurieA posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 9:37 AM
They'll at least have to try to make the Daz figures compatible yes since they are the most popular.
Laurie
dphoadley posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 9:48 AM
I don't consider IDL to be a gimmick! To me, it looks like it approaches the power of the Vray addon in Max! And for a lot less money!
dph
Tashar59 posted Mon, 24 January 2011 at 3:50 PM
Quote - because if DAZ does we will at least see some real development again, instead of all these flashy gimmicks.
Riiiiggghhht. That was a joke wasn't it? As LaurieA pointed out. Not much money for development. Would end up like Hex. They have spent to much time and money on DS to bother with Poser. It would end up rotting on a shelf and we would be forced to go with DS or just move on to something else. Also we would lose the competition which keeps both moving. With one gone, development would slow down even more. Not counting many don't like one app over the other. Not good for everyone concerned.