Forum: Photography


Subject: Constructive Criticism

Lilgooser opened this issue on Jun 14, 2001 ยท 13 posts


Lilgooser posted Thu, 14 June 2001 at 1:28 PM

...Just looking for constructive criticism. I just got my degree in computer science, so I'm not much of an "artist". I hope Im not posting too much:). These where taken on a vacation to Gulf Shores.

Lilgooser posted Thu, 14 June 2001 at 1:28 PM

two:)

Lilgooser posted Thu, 14 June 2001 at 1:29 PM

Last one:)

Syyd posted Thu, 14 June 2001 at 1:40 PM

Well, if you want to take me on vacation with you, I'd be glad to sit in that water and talk about anything computers LOL...


bsteph2069 posted Thu, 14 June 2001 at 1:59 PM

You caught the bubbles. I Neato. congrats. I always wanted to catch somethign transatory. Like that. OK creative critism. What is the principal subject matter? You may want to enlarge the picture and crop to highlight the subject. But the colors look fine. Bsteph


RJH posted Thu, 14 June 2001 at 3:55 PM

Hey Lil this maybe what Bsteph was talking about then again maybe not. if you get rid of the extra stuff the subject stands out more. This could even be cropped some more on the left

Lilgooser posted Thu, 14 June 2001 at 4:41 PM

...Ahhh.. I see:). I wanted to get the beach a little more cause it is a vacation picture. You know, "here I am in front of the water" kinda thing.


billglaw posted Fri, 15 June 2001 at 12:07 AM

The third picture is well composed. With a catchy title it would be a winner. All that work, building the sand city. They are having a fine day.


bsteph2069 posted Fri, 15 June 2001 at 5:28 AM

Personally I'm a great fan of bubbles. So I concentrated upon the first picture although they are all fine pictures and the sand castle is the TajMahal! RJH was right I figured to centralize the main subject matter. The first picture had two potential subjects to me. The bubbles and the little lady. I was unsure which was the real subject since they were so close. I realize getting bubbles and a person is a hard thing to do. So. I improvised and added some cut's and pastes. I hope you approve. I figure this way you see bothe subjects at the same time. Bsteph

Lilgooser posted Fri, 15 June 2001 at 11:16 AM

..hehe.. I was waiting for someone to add more bubbles.. I also did that a while ago, just playing around.. Thank you all for your comments, these are really some of the first pictures I've EVER taken, aside from the "will you take this for me". Never had a camera before.

JordyArt posted Fri, 15 June 2001 at 7:24 PM

I know everyone's into this cropping bits out to centralise bit, but I think pic two is brilliant - BECAUSE of the deckchair in the background!?! I dunno, there's something about it being there that makes it a bit 'holiday brochure-ish' and there's a nice space to put some text...... and how did you guys clone those bubbles so well?!?


bsteph2069 posted Fri, 15 June 2001 at 8:18 PM

That's true Jordy. I missed it. Personally I do a lot of photo retouch just for fun so I get practice. There's many tutorials. As well. Bsteph


Lilgooser posted Fri, 15 June 2001 at 8:36 PM

Yeah.. lots of practice. Of course.. moving the person and the lamp wasn't very easy:)