Egout by pmermino
Close
Hover over top left image to zoom.
Click anywhere to exit.
Members remain the original copyright holder in all their materials here at Renderosity. Use of any of their material inconsistent with the terms and conditions set forth is prohibited and is considered an infringement of the copyrights of the respective holders unless specially stated otherwise.
Description
Another test picture in Vue 6. I have rendered the same scene in Radiosity mode (top) and in Ambiant Occlusion...(down)...
Could be interesting as a comparison ...
Comments (32)
BGHart
WOW! What a perspective. This really pulls me in. :) Love the colors, textures and lighting too. I prefer the second image because there is more contrast.
WhopperNnoonWalker-
Fantastic scene and lightning
chrispoole
Great comparison, I feel the AO looks more authentic for this type of render and from the small amount in using Vue 6 it's a lot quicker as well, I see you have used the area lights as well they look wonderful I go with AO on this one, and its hardly noticeable on outside shots as well.
fairy-storm
Really great, the second one i prefer more, the colors come out clearer, but the first one seems to be more realistic.
dlk30341
Well done :) I prefer #1 for lighting & realism.
IQ200
Excellent artwork! Awesome lighting and textures. Bravo!
sittingblue
I am wondering what was the time difference. The color bleeding in the radiosity render makes it the preferred render for me.
pmermino
Time ratio is about 1 to 2. 60 minutes for the radiosity mode and 32 min for the AO mode ... But it depends on what kinf of scene you render .... This is not a rule. .... only for this picture
wabe
I prefer #1 for smoother and more natural light. A super scene Patrick.
FantastArt
Awesome scene and render...Hard to say which one I like better...maybe I prefer the 2nd one because the lights look a bit more intensiv...
rodluc2001
both are nice... would be nice if the water make some caustics on walls... but maybe will be in vue 7 :)
BigGreenFurryThing
Excellent stuff and thanks for sharing. Definitely the second image: contrast and lighting are better particularly on the fan. Or maybe it's because the light in #2 looks like a film photo?
Surama
Wow...both are most excellent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Morgano
I have to agree with Surama: they are both terrific. I suppose that I prefer the radiosity version for the lesser contrast. Very interesting and informative post - thanks.
2zuluone
Hi, top picture appears darker and more gritty than the bottom picture - though IMHO the water in the second picture is more realistic
servo
I guess I disagree with most here... The shadows are un-realistically sharp with the 2nd (ambient occlusion) pic. The first one's radiosity shadows look much more realistic.
timefighter
WOW!!! I think the Ambient Occlusion one is the better of the two. Well Done Patrick.
Digimon
Fantastic example!!! The radiosity version looks more real, and there is greater tonal range in the light and shadow areas. The occlusion lighting (Heard it was better?) looks harsher and has less range. Thanks you for this awesome demonstration! And fantastic scene!!
gerberc
Intersting comparison. The radiosity version looks much more realistic i.m.o. Thanks for the demonstration!
petemohr
excellent light, colors and scene! i prefer the first image, the light and the soft shadows seem more natural. very beautiful done! :)
FrenchKiss
Sublime travail et lumie! Bravo!!!
kenwas
Number 1 for me. Excellent work as always Patrick!
SunsetHunter
Superb rendering of a fascinating scene - looks like a computer game! i prefer the top image - the less contrast actually looks more realistic. Still; they are both awesome!
cermit
great I prefer the top version
Krid
perfect realistic scene(s) with excellent lightning
madame
Les deux images sont superbement rliss... difficile d'en choisir une :) ! Le rendu est parfait et j'aime beaucoup l' ambiance. Excellent travail, Patrick !!
gmvgmvgmv
Either way, great pic! Superb modeling with a wonderfully realistic environment!!
spider1313
I just love the diversity of your works, Patrick and this one here is no exception! Like 'em both, but since we have to vote '-)...I will also choose the first 'though I am wondering what kind of machine you are running to render this in an hour?
lingrif
Incredibly real image. Lighing is awesome. Excellent work!
calum5
Cool,tried blending the 2 .:)