Rocks,and water look excellent

really well done - colors & water fantast. - EXCLT

Saruman Sucks:0( Great picture!

Awesome work,great surface and water!!

Agree... a wonderful picture, with an excellent terrain, pov and coloring. Great postwork too !

I like this one very much; Sky is awesome; great PoV and water (maybe a little less transparency depth, but I like the water's surface), too! How did you create the flock of birds (using what in PS)?

Agree with above! My question as Lutz too, how you create the birds? Excellent work!!!

I agree with the others, very good work

excellent terrain and water! and the details of the birds fits very well! =)

Wonderful atmosphere and a great idea (and output) for postprocess.

all I can say is : wow this is excellent!

great idea and a very good work

Well I think the image is good, but I don't like the birds.

very cool postwork i like it a lot. Water and Terrain are wonderful too

cool scenery, a bit surreal, a bit fantasy, I like it... and terrain, surface and water are excellent

Sorry, I'm late. I like the mystic mood. Reminds me at Hitchcocks 'Birds'. Look of sky and terrain is mysterious. Water color is well selected, surfline is very natural. Postpro... very good. Combination excellent !

Again i am late .. :( Let me say this is X-Lars-like ;) Very beautiful scene! And always some special detail - great postwork!

This is so beautiful!!! I love how you did the birds. Excellent!

great water, looks a bit bloody, great colors in the water. as often an outstanding atmosphere, pov and terrain. surface fits very well to this scene

Thank you so much for all your comments and suggestions to my picture.

You ask about the birds? (LutzB and Dotthy) .. well, I wanted to add some dark birds .. big flock of Crebain Saruman spy-birds. I ended by taking my pen and paper and made a little drawing of each bird, then scanned the drawing into my computer and added each bird individually in PS! ... cut/paste, scaling and rotating, groping into larger and larger groups of birds, cutting an pasting again and again and again ..
Drawings are not that good but here they are:

ISSE: Glad you mention the rocks and water, I worked on them :-)
arthez: That is so good to hear!
fractalneil: ha ha .. yes Saruman has spies everywhere G
garcia: You also mention the surface. That really makes me happy.
hillrunner: So glad about your comment and rating!
LutzB: Very pleased you like it, and for your suggestion. Yes I can see now that the water should have had a little less trans. Thanks for advise :-)
Dotthy: Glad you like it. Now I also explained the postwork ;-)
puenktchen: Good to hear you think so.
eponce: Thanks for commment on terrain and water.. and the birds :-)
Chudus: Good to hear your positive comment on atm and postwork.
Golog: That wow says it all to me ;-)
Elana: Thank you very much.
Xabre: I wanted to make Crebain (ie. they flock in a cloud-like formation in great numbers). Any suggestions to improve these "birds"?
Blitzz-Licht: That you like both postwork, water and terrain makes me so happy.
engineer: I love your analysis!! also pleased that you like both scene, ter, srf and water.
Pelican: Are you late? What a wonderful comment from you. Ah, yes Hitchcocks birds (or maybe LOTR? ;-). Glad you like all these parts in the picture and that you think it is excellent :-)
Margit1: Ah, but you are just in time. .. ha ha .. X-lars-like. Thanks (I think ;-), yes I like to add a little different sometimes. Glad you like it.
SophiaDeer: I appreciate your comment on the image and the creation of the Crebain.
XR666: Ha ha ... yes bloody water it is. Thanks for your kind comments on all these elements, and your send message to me that you also liked the birds :-D

What a wonderful job with the birds. You have me anxious to try some post work now.