Which One??? by Belgareth
Close
Hover over top left image to zoom.
Click anywhere to exit.
Members remain the original copyright holder in all their materials here at Renderosity. Use of any of their material inconsistent with the terms and conditions set forth is prohibited and is considered an infringement of the copyrights of the respective holders unless specially stated otherwise.
Description
Thanks for looking and thank you to all who looked and commented on my last render.
Here are two renders and I would like you to choose which one looks better. The images are identical except for the terrain map. (So not identical actually...lol)
The render on the left is using an Arial photo used by Adrian Farnsworth in his scene North-West Derby included in Vue4 Pro.
The other is an Arial Photo I got off the net but is of lesser quality.
So. Let me know so I can post the favourite render here:
Comments (24)
kazuki_k
seems like the scene in Pearl Harbor, rite? well i like the one on the left =)
nanotyrannus
I like the one on the left as well, the one on the right is just too pixelated. I like the motion blur of the planes and the lighting on the terrain, Great Job!
Belgareth
Thank you for your comments, and yes...lol I happened to watch the film today, and though I don't condone war, I was inspired by the visuals in the film to do something similar. I was going to mention where I got the inspiration from when everyone who is going to choose, chooses:) But maybe I should say that now...lol Thanks for your choice and it is my favourite too, but not entirely mine as like I said in the write-up, the Photo came from another scene. Take care and Happy rendering:)
Tebok
We'll they are German Aircraft :) I like the one on the left.
ArtJosephNito
Like the one on the left, And whoa, they're flying dangerously so close to each other...
esper77
I like the one on the left. I agree with nanotyrannus about the right one being too pixelated. Great job with the motion blur :)
sittingblue
What a great idea for a picture! I like the picture on the left. Excellent artwork!!
FrenchKiss
I like the one on the left too!! Great idea Gareth and excellent job!
raffyraffy
Very beautiful idea, great trick. I like both pics. Bravo and vote!
Kath13
Great image Gareth, I prefer the image on the left. Nice job and well done.
rodluc2001
left image background are better for me !
kenwas
Seems like the left wins and I agree!
Belgareth
Well. It does look like we have a winner...lol Left will be rendered out later today and submitted tomorrow. Have to upload my entry for the Vue April challenge to my gallery today. Thanks for looking and thanks for choosing.
thomaskrahn
The one to the left is my favourite! The landscape just seems more dramtatic and interesting... and another thought : I think it would be cool with having the motionblur and the ground and the clouds (a little less motionblur than you've got on the planes), and then having the planes in focus. I'd love to see how that would look. But it's a great picture already :)
CDN_Merlin
Left but, you should unblur the planes or blur the background to make it more beleivable.
dlk30341
Fabulous....I choose the left because of the clairty of the details on the terrain itself. Superb effects!!!
Margit1
Fantastic image! Excellent idea, details and pov. For me the left one is better :)
erka
Both landscapes look great but the left has more detail and is less pixelated. I think it will look even more realistic without the motion blur on the planes. (As if the shot was taken from within another plane flying with the rest).
nish
Yes Gareth, I agree with erka. Nevertheless, an excellent one!!!
sacada
I go the left. Thought this might be a 3d cross thing first. Both are Excellent.
zxcvb
Excellent work , i like the one on the left best as well , very well done:-)
Mikeangelo
Yes the left wins for me also, excellent work. Dave
starwalker38
I like the one on the felt. Fantastic idea!
shayhurs
Left wins; especially with the motion applied to the fighters (Me-109s I believe)