double render by rodluc2001
Close
Hover over top left image to zoom.
Click anywhere to exit.
Members remain the original copyright holder in all their materials here at Renderosity. Use of any of their material inconsistent with the terms and conditions set forth is prohibited and is considered an infringement of the copyrights of the respective holders unless specially stated otherwise.
Description
hi all ! a try to set the relative render quality between 3D studio and Vue, 3D studio is a very expensive professional tool: difference is clear... but Vue can do great render...
what do you think about this ?
(set the scene and lights in 3d Studio : many hours, set the scene in Vue a couple of minutes...)
ah i forget... time of Vue rendering 3h 9 min.
Luca.
Comments (32)
kitz
Woooooowww ! excellent composition !
Irish
Both of these images are awesome but I do prefer Vue version - the lighting in it seems better, especially at the window. Bravo!!
gillbrooks
Looks very interesting. I'll have to give this a try some time ... thanks :)
Umbetro38
This is a perfect work - like the room and shadows - Gratulation
chrysalide
it's an excellent work and idea, i like the shadows effect on the first. the lighting and the render are very good. have a good day
bigbraader
Very interesting concept and educational as well. Seems you get (far) better looking/smoother soft shadows in Max, but actually I think it is possible to make something closer to this in Vue, with higher antialiasing (if you didn't already try this). Wonderful work btw. :)
rodluc2001
thanx bigbraader, in vue the quality is Broadcast, but also in MAX are not the best (image was renderd in only 25 minutes...), but yes ! you right about quality of Vue.
Djeser
Great comparison; I'd say Vue Pro holds up pretty well! (Love the scene and lighting, by the way!)
Phoe
Absolutely amazing . The lighting is perfect . I like the idea . Excellent work V
IQ200
Excellent images/ Vue is cool!!!
sittingblue
It makes me think that 3d studio was written with assembly language. Thanks for sharing!
zaberc
Excellent images!!! the render are interesting !!!
sacada
Interesting comparison. Vue stands up very well. Looks like you only used a broadcast render in Vue. Hours to minutes setup is a large difference. Another great reason to choose Vue. BTW... excellent image.
FrenchKiss
Considering the difference in price of the two programs, I'd say that Vue is excellent in its category. A fun and very interesting experiment!
BGHart
I prefer the vue picture. The lighting is softer. Excellent work.
TheWingedOne
I'm not shure about which image is "better". Both have their special style. Many thanks for the background info - very interesting comparism. :)
Belgareth
Excellent test. Well thought out and carried out. Thanks for the info:)
nhirschberger
Interesting information. Excellent work !
pmermino
Very interesting comparison... I think it's possible to increase the quality of soft shadows in Vue by using oversampling in this way : render the picture with a very large resolution : 4000x 3000 for example... and then resize it to 800x600 in a 2D soft... it could help ... thank you for sharing your work and ideas
Arturzinho
Great test, but I can't tell the best. You have both... Lucky :o) Thanks :o)
rodluc2001
Sure Pmermino, Vue version would be better with extra size and superior quality of rendering. i think in that case the only difference would be the color-light reflection made by radiosity... (in 3dmax you can see a little soft yellow light around the statue, in vue statue are grey...)
Sylvia
I find both scenes
FantasticSoftwares are important in designing a scene... but the talent and creativity of an Artist is what counts most at the end... And You are a GREAT Artist no matter what!! Excellentpignifer
Fun to look at and educational too! I do believe I like the MAX version better. What fun though to "push" Vue just to see what could be done!
BigGreenFurryThing
MAX version is definitely the more realistic of the two but considering the price difference Vue holds up fairly well.
sunfirexed
EXCELLENT IMAGE. THE MATERIALS ARE FANTASTICALLY ASSIGN.
coa
Excellent comparison! The lights on the right wall look different..1 window light in Vue and 2 in Max.
rodluc2001
yes coa, this is true, but the sencond windows in Vue exist... unfortunelly the light is too right in image and is hidden for vue render
zxcvb
Stunning images , your work in both programs is amazing , well done and a vote:-)
Panic912
Excellent artwork! Very well done!!
Kutter
Great comparison Rod! I did something similar to this myself some time ago (never posted, wasn't good enough in either LOL) and it was amazing just how close you really can get with Vue. For my money max's renderer will always win out. I render all my scenes in Max first to test textures and UVW unwrapped ones especially. When in Max things always, always look superior, but thats relected in the price i guess. This is a fine image in both versions, and some excellent work all round. thx for sharing, I always find your work interesting and original.