For those that have seen my WIPs, should I go with Trail of Tears part 1, 2 or 3? Just can't make up my mind. Any ideas?

Wellll, since I've entered too, I should suggest one I think would do badly. ;-) I like the first one, with the snow. They're all good, but the others suffer a little from poseritis. Sorry, don't hate me. I can't really talk. I'm suck big time with poser to the extent that I don't even try anymore. hence my picture was set early morning before anyone woke up. Good luck.

I refuse to answer on the grounds you may beat me. ;c)They're all excellent, but if you want to beat me, I think number two is your bet.

First I compared the hits on viewing & comments. Next I looked at each one, My fav is the original (#1). What caught my eye was the atmosphere of coldness & the portrayal of despair. (IMHO) Good Luck!!

I too think the first one was the most atmospheric and held a lot of emotion and dispair. 8) Catlin

I prefer the first one as well (and I'm not entering). It had that painful desolate feel about it much more than the others.

Well one thing I know is that when I change my mind and resubmit,I kick myself.So go with the first choice always.

I prefer the first one too. It's very atmosphereic and full of memotion and it's technically exellent too. I like the ratio of the image too, it's perfect for the composition.

Well, I'm with the majority here. l #1.

Ok I am convinced. I will go with number one, which was after all the one I originally intended to enter. Thanks for all your comments. That's what I love about this forum, everyone is so helpful and friendly. And Drawbridgep I only originally bought poser to put figures into my bryce landscapes, that was back when I updated to Bryce 3. Have B5 but still use P4.

I feel really bad now. I didn't mean it to sound like I was taking a dig at your poser work, which is so much better than anything I could do. I just find it really difficult to achieve natural results in Poser and anyone that can even get the limbs to stay in the correct place gets my vote. Sorry. (I'll be hiding in shame now.)

Its Ok I didn't take it as a dig, it was a good point. Just that I rarely nowadays use poser as poser, if you know what I mean, because you can't get an image to look right very easily in poser. Prefer Bryce, for all its little quirks and the fact that I am still learning. You are never to old to learn. I spent a lot of time lurking in the poser forum, learning to get better results. And time is about the only thing I have plenty of.