Forum Coordinators: RedPhantom
Poser - OFFICIAL F.A.Q (Last Updated: 2024 Nov 21 6:06 am)
Attached Link: http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=33300&Start=73&Artist=februus&ByArtist=Yes
Here's a link to a Deja Thoris image I did awhile back, I've also done several John Carter pics that are in my gallery.As a John Carter fan and reader for more years than I wish to admit, I would love to be able to see what fellow fans could create. However, there is one major problem -- ERB, Inc. ERB, Inc. is merciless in its protection of any and all things Burroughs related. Even though the copyright on many of Burroughs' works has long since expired, ERB, Inc. has resorted to TRADEMARKING names, places, etc. within the books as a further form of protection. And, yes, they have went after fans whose only "crime" was posting fan-fiction and/or graphics related to ERB works. They do not tolerate anything that, in their opinion, would diminish the financial worth of ERB related works. This might be a worthy matter for discussion in the new Copyright Laws forum. It appears that ERB, Inc. relaizes that the copyright protection is gone on much of ERB's work, yet continue their prosecutions. It appears, IMO, that they do it with the goal of simply wearing the "perpetrator" down with appeals and legal bills. Well, I really had not meant to babble on so long, but it may help explain why there is such a dearth of John Carter and Mars related materials.
Hmm . Here's where I earn some naite points. I've been accessing all the classic ERB novels online, where they're posted in their entirety for anyone to read. I can even get them on my handheld if I want! For some silly reason I figured if they were being draconian about copyright those texts wouldn't be so freelay available on a mainstream literature source. Is it mayhap less a copyright issue and more an attempt to keep some sort of "purity" thing going with the original works, I wonders?
For some silly reason I figured if they were being draconian about copyright those texts wouldn't be so freelay available on a mainstream literature source. Is it mayhap less a copyright issue and more an attempt to keep some sort of "purity" thing going with the original works, I wonders?<<< Could be. However, if in fact the copyright is expired their reasoning behind some of the measures they have taken is moot. If the copyright is expired it is expired and they have no legal rights over it. Now, it is my understanding that all of ERB's works previous to 1923 are now in the public domain. If that is so, then ERB, Inc. is simply trying to prevent anyone from dimishing the financial worth of the properties so they, ERB, Inc., can reap greater profit from Mr. Burroughs' work. I also think part of the reason you will find most of ERB's pre-1923 work so readily available is that it is places like Gutenberg and other sources that would call ERB, Inc.'s bluff. There are occassional discussions in the ERB newsgroup that are interesting when someone tries to issue a version of one of ERB's works that has not been "authorized" by ERB, Inc. Then there is the tale of ERB, Inc. suing a fan of the Mars stories because he had named his restaurant-bar "Barsoom." If you check U.S. Trademark records online, your will see that "barsoom" is trademarked by ERB, Inc. as are a number of other John Carter and Tarzan related terms and names. They cannot protect them under copyright law since the copyrights on much of the material has expired and since, it is my understanding, you cannot protect names or terms under copyright law so they have resorted to trademark infringement cases. I've never raised the issue with my attorney since I've never had the need, but I am curious now so I may when I next meet with him. It would be interesting to see the reaction from ERB, Inc. if someone decided to do an illustrated "Princess of Mars" novel or comic online. If I understand copyright law correctly, there is not a great deal they LEGALLY could do. But if it was a small outfit launching it, ERB, Inc. could either intimidate them to cease or bury them in legal bills through appeal after appeal. I wonder what they thought of Bo Derek's "Tarzan" movie?
Yes, all great points. I just wonder. My intention was (still is, actually) to amuse myself rendering "cool" scenes from the novels as I re-read them; not a full-on graphic novel by any means but certainly could be considered illustrating the text. Hmm. I'm just Quixotic (and cocky) enough to dare them on this one ... perhaps not immediately (I'm way too busy right now for the luxury of letting playtime affect business) but soon. Hmm again. dons pots and pans to test the fit
Burroughs fans or people who never heard of him, check out this guys (Francois Miville Deschenes) art NOW!: http://gaspe.cgaspesie.qc.ca/~crioux/fmd/ The only person I recall attempting ERB martian stuff is februus, as mentioned above. I think most younger Poser fans have never been exposed to such things. You almost have to me from the 60's or early 80's when the books where released in new paperback editions, most recently with Michael Whelan or Joe Jusko art. A banth might be possible (put more legs on the Poser lion), I've seen a multi-armed female character somewhere, so a multi armed, male like Tars Tarkas may be possible. Modeling the head would be like a highly modified alien gray with tusks. As for the (4 armed) white apes, there isn't even a real honest-to-God Poser gorilla yet. The impossible dream. Dejah Thoris would be easiest, a dark-haired red skinned babe with fantastic jewelry and one of those "Frazetta Head-dresses" That would be one cool prop that I've awaited in vain. I saw a "fantasy warrior" in one of the stores that was damn close to John Carter.
Thanks, folks. My work is now extending to the fulfillment of a great fantasy pastiche of Burroughs wherein Tarzan has an adventure on Mars (Barsoom) I'm still in the formative phase, but have created several characters that should be familiar to ERB fans for the sheer joy of it. I found the perfect mesh deformer for poser models in z brush, so when the storyline is complete I'll be doing chapters in a quasi illustrative and episodic style for on-line viewing. Ta! februus
Attached Link: http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=52222&Start=1&Sectionid=0&WhatsNew=Yes
A little sample of ERBWykkadOne, I think the flier looks great, but for me the wings don't fit. My own vision of the Barsoomian flier (formed mostly from the ACE paperback versions) had the flier as more boat-like, with vertical spars sportig various pennants and flags. But hey, that's only my humble opinion. I guess whatever design finds it's way into the most and most like artwrok, will become the standard. Your work is most certainly good enough to become the norm. Mike
This site uses cookies to deliver the best experience. Our own cookies make user accounts and other features possible. Third-party cookies are used to display relevant ads and to analyze how Renderosity is used. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understood our Terms of Service, including our Cookie Policy and our Privacy Policy.
Another lurker pokes his oar in for a moment ... I recently bought Poser 4 for the most mundane of modeling needs, but all work and no play, so they say. Coincidentally I've also recently begun re-reading my tattered old copies of ERB's Barsoom novels; how could someone in that position not immediately think of rendering great scenes from those old tales, eh? Therein lies the rub: I simply cannot believe this is a new idea. Impossible. Yet a search of Web resources has thus far turned up not a thing. I'd as soon not reinvent any wheels, tread on any artistic toes, nor overlook the chance to spare myself some effort in my playtime. :-) Does anyone have word on where ERB's great characters are hiding? Can you share? Many thanks!