Steve bell suggested we use the Tutorial atmosphere that were made to "...It was designed to emphasize sky, fog and haze. It's actually the scene that is used in the small atmosphere previews What do you think? Then all of you who have already submitted, have to do a new render of your atmosphere??? I just had a look. A small part of the horizon is visible. Please answer here with your opinion, so we will atleast get this challenge running. But we also can leave our rules as they are and each of us creates his own small terrain to show light and shadows. :-) Guitta

Good idea, and will make comparison far easier--simply because the foreground won't (subliminally) influence one's take on the final result. ta, -Sascha.rb

Everybody has his (her) own idea of a challenge. I do it best as I can in listening to users opinion too. The rules are made atleast by me. It is anough work to do a challenge, believe me, especally this one. Please feel free to participate if you like. Guitta

I like the present rules as they are, however will be flexible to what ever the group opinions may be.

Anyhow, you can do both:-) Use your own terrain or use the Vue scene, whatever you like. The important is the atmosphere:-)

The rules are well established at this point. It should be better to let us the choice of the terrain. And Guitta, as usual, you can judge if a picture follow the rules or not. This system seems a good one ;=) Yves