I agree on the irregular tubing, they're more pronounced than the first one, and more interesting than the second one. Very cool.

Thanks Rod. It does have a more worn look. :) I like the first one as well, but with the transparency map it gets a lot heavier.

Yup, & render time I'll bet.

Message edited on: 12/29/2005 16:35

My pute is due for an update, I barley finished my last piece and I had to watch for smoke...Whew! Comps with stuff like this would really send my edsel over the edge. LOL

As an amateur:

I find #1 rather unconvincing. A bit too obviously x/y co-ordinated. But it's a nice texture.

I quite like both #2 & #3, but if you could find a way to get that "#1 Offset Z-type" pattern to work radially on them, then that would be excellent! Hard to do though...

And I have no idea how to start to do that...

Cheers,
Diolma

(Who has to go to bed now, and won't be back til after New Year - got to go visit Mother, who is not internet connected..)

And then it's going to take me 3/4 days to catch up on the forums (fora??)

Message edited on: 12/29/2005 16:51

I know what you mean. I wouldnt mind an update with a couple of ghz either, especially with this scene. Ive already put in more detail on the door than i normally do on a model and its not even complete. Then it will need surroundings with even more details... :D Rochr patiently awaits the inevitable "Out of memory" message

Diolma, You need to convince the mother about the advantages with a T1 line. And Happy new year! :)

I would cast my vote for #3. The modeling looks great on all 3, but the irregularity of the piping on #3 adds a human touch; as if this is an advanced tech civilization, but things still get installed slightly crooked, or get worn-out. I look forward to trying to spot this among all the other details you put in your renders.

Well, Fancy a bloke like you asking the likes of me about your modeling.......the world is full of surprises!! LOL I like the second one, not overdone with the inner slats and I feel that adding more items on it wont overpower it as it would the last. Its a shame the firsts inner metal mesh looks like its going one way and I'm sure you dont wont people's comments on something silly like that after working so hard on the other stuff to be added. ;) Its obvious thats its going to be a hit as all your other work is, so do what you do best.........just keep on modeling! ;) @ Diolma If your having trouble with your mother and no internet, get her to visit you......when she sleeps at night, you can catch up on here!! LOL

Yeah, the 3 is the best. But I'd also like to see you try to get a more irregular slots on the inside. BTW, Rudy, this reminded me... Have you ever finished the flying cities image you worked on for the Space Opera challenge? PS. I've been waiting for my new computer ten days now and I won't get it untill after New Year. I certainly hope so, because I just got Cinema 9.5 and would like to have something stronger to run it on. And it would be a nice gift from myself for my birthday on January 7. :-)

I like number 3..

Looks good. I liked 1 but that depends on the scale. Since it is huge scale then I would not go for that one. 1 works if it is about 2-3 meters in diameter.

If you go from one to three it looks like the objects evolution. Yes the alternating #3 looks like the model of choice. Evolution??? You say Sans I no, some times I dont know what the hell Im writing lol. Look forward to seeing another Rochr image;)

Rochr, nice job as usual. I would also agree with your selection of #3 and I like the last pic. Was wandering if the grate system (just the bottom part) could also offer outside lighting for the building with light shining through slats as from within. Just a thought. Looking forward to the end product.

You know what I like..Now I can tell people honestly that Rochr asked me for advice....The girls will love this...:)

Thats a pretty decent wip you got there rudy.

I like 3 alot. The detail in the grating on #1 is awesome too, but it kinda dissappears when you look at it at a glance. great work by the way.

Hang on! The tentacled-one wants OUR opinions? Is he unwell? We, who are not worthy so much as to clean his monitor screen with the rags of our meagre talent....?

Even aliens need to lower the standard and address mortal hu-mans from time to time... :D

Still reckon 2 is the best to use but hey, Who am I!! LOL Love the extras being added Rudy......I think you may be having more the one image to show of this modeling after its been completed........different angles to see NUMBER 2!!!

slightly irregular one defenitely! great WIP there btw, though I can see where you're commming from that it misses something... Maybe you need to really throw the composition around a few times to get some inspiration. Or you could think up a story of what all the pieces are doing in the image.

I like #1. Too late.

Just got back today, from visiting Mother. Many thanks for the "Diolma, You need to convince the mother about the advantages with a T1 line. And Happy new year! :)" sentiment. It's a lovely thought but, alas, Mother is over 80, suffers from Altzheimer's(SP?), has no computer at all and is not really interested in getting one. Not only that, she lives in a backwater village south of Guildford (Surrey, UK), where there's no cable connection. Ah well. She's still sweet tho' (if a little forgetful) :-) Happy new year to you too, Rochr, and my wishes to you for many more of them. Cheers, Diolma