Opinions Please by Staceymb1
Close
Hover over top left image to zoom.
Click anywhere to exit.
Members remain the original copyright holder in all their materials here at Renderosity. Use of any of their material inconsistent with the terms and conditions set forth is prohibited and is considered an infringement of the copyrights of the respective holders unless specially stated otherwise.
Description
Hey,
I don't usually open up the comments for both critical and non-critical. Most of the time I don't need a critique. Art is subjective. But, in this case, I need critiques. Not sarcasim, but a critique.
I'm trying to make a demon teacher. She is suppose to be just a tad pretty. I need this for a project I am doing for my digital imaging 2 course. So, opinions would be very helpful. I have labeled each render. Which one do you think looks the best? It will be on a flame background, but not the one shown.
~Stacey~
Comments (6)
Mattsville
Nice work, very cool. I like number 2!
Fidelity2
Perfect. 5+!!!
IsaoShi
Hi Stacey The monochrome hair in 1 and 4 doesn't look right to me. 2 and 3 are both good... 2 is definitely the more demonic, but 3 is perhaps a tad prettier, even if it's only skin deep. Izi
Gaiadriel
I happen to like the monochromatics of the hair in #1, and those tonal elements of clarity the best. Of all, I like 4 least. It feels very incongruent to the eye. 2 is less incongruent to me, but again, something indistinct about it. If the tad pretty thing is key, then #3's lighting and tones bring a semi-softness to her face. Good luck on this. I'm no afficionado by any stretch of the imagination, but hope this helps at least a little.
Angelsinger
Hope it's not too late to submit feedback! I know you need this for your course. I like 2 & 3. The lighting in both highlights her face in such a way in which there is attractiveness in her features, but also bear the effects of a flaming surrounding. In #4, however, she simply appears to be a red-skinned creature. #1 doesn't reflect the flames at all. IF you twisted my arm and MADE me pick between 2 & 3 (lol), I would choose 3. I love the lighting in this one especially because it not only makes her appear to be engulfed in a fiery background, but shows her features more distinctly than in #2. Also, I personally think that no matter what type of flame background you choose, #3 will seem to 'belong' in any of them more than #2. (Because #2 has a distinct redness about it, whereas #3 could easily fit into a scene lit by something as simple as campfire or a scene immersed in flames).
Mondwin
Briliant done...bravissima!V:DDD.Hugsxx