Mon, Nov 18, 12:59 PM CST

"God told me to!"

Writers People posted on Oct 12, 2004
Open full image in new tab Zoom on image
Close

Hover over top left image to zoom.
Click anywhere to exit.


Members remain the original copyright holder in all their materials here at Renderosity. Use of any of their material inconsistent with the terms and conditions set forth is prohibited and is considered an infringement of the copyrights of the respective holders unless specially stated otherwise.

Description


I'm kinda freaked at the moment. We've recently moved into our own home (yay!), and on one side of our house we have an Atheist family, and on the other a devout Christian family of unknown denomination. The Christian family has an autistic boy, John, aged 10 - quite severely developmentally delayed; likeable enough. He calls out over the fence to me, almost incessantly, begging to come over to play with my son. It's a bit irritating and makes me not want to go outside sometimes, which irritates me more, but I mostly I'm okay with it for now. I'm hoping he just needs some time to learn what our household routine and boundaries are so that he can learn what is an appropriate request and/or when to make those requests. I limit his visits and make sure he knows what the boundaries are about coming over. It's almost silly, too, because he's really not interested in the things we like to do - he has very opposite interests to my son, who although not intellectually delayed at all, has many of the same autistic problems... but John wants to come over nonetheless. Anyway, sorry, rambling. :-) Must get to the crux of it and stop wasting your precious time. By the way, none of the above is why I am freaked. :-) Here's the gritty: This afternoon, just before he came to visit, John called over the fence to me and after some conversation about various things, he told me, "Dad says God says good parents should smack their children." I'm not Christian, so I don't know - is this the general consensus? Is this what the Bible teaches? I don't like to judge anyone's beliefs, but somehow I find it impossible not to in this particular case. It seems almost sick to me that a person should be able to hide behind their God in order to hit their child - or any person for that matter. If they feel it is necessary to smack their child for whatever reason or purpose, okay, they are entitled to make that decision, but why do they need to blame God? Why not at least take responsibility for it? And this man is actually a school teacher who is supposed to be educated with alternative methods of discipline: how can he call smacking something that he must do in the name of God in order to be a good parent? It sounds almost like an excuse to make hitting an integral part of his parenting, to allow him to hit his kids at his leisure, and have a damn fine reason to do it - "God told me to!" That's why I'm a bit freaked.
Please understand that I am not judging Christians at all - only this particular idea of using God as an excuse to harm another person, particularly a child. Hopefully the distinction is discernible in my writing. If anyone has found this viewpoint offensive, please accept my sincerest apologies.

Comments (5)


)

Metonicus

7:02AM | Tue, 12 October 2004

Ok. Well, I'm inclinded to think that the child may have chosen his own wording. I believe the phrase is "Spare the rod, spoil the child." Not really in the bible I think, but this seems to me to be one of those "Kids say the darndest things" where the father may have said something and the child either misinterpreted it or mispoke. I work in a jail with lots of people whose parents probably should have smacked them, and at the same time quite a few who's parents smacked them for too many reasons. Either way the lesson of right and wrong was lost in the translation and they ended up in jail. If I'm wrong walk over to your neighbor and smack him. Then tell him God told you to.

netsia

7:33AM | Tue, 12 October 2004

Having read your works, I can understand that 'bells' would go off in your head. A child talking about being hit, father a teacher, understandable. Being autistic, John does not make connections well. Perhaps it is only by raising hackles, pushing buttons that he gets attention. One bright note is that he is trying to make a connection with you, kindness/what ever positive attention you can give him may be what he needs. God/Great Spirit/Creator, what ever term is used for Higher Power fosters love, John's father may be working from a point of (1)guilt~my child is not normal (2)exasperation~what AM I going to do with this child or (3)~the worst~Apathy, not wanting to connect with this 'difficult' child. Whatever the reason(s), you have had a 'lesson' placed in front of you. You will do what you feel is right. God/Great Spirit/Creator will love you for it. :) Take care

)

TallPockets

11:47AM | Tue, 12 October 2004

"One bright note is that he is trying to make a connection with you, kindness/what ever positive attention you can give him may be what he needs" - well said, Netsia.

servo

11:45PM | Tue, 12 October 2004

From another Christian's perspective: Actually, the statement, "spare the rod, spoil the child is in Proverbs, in the old testament. But if you read all of it in context, it's very clear that corporeal punishment is acceptable ONLY within the bounds of careful understanding and NEVER to the excessive point of abuse. Striking a child lightly on a resilient posterior, just enough to trigger a painful memory associated with a disobedient behavior is, in fact, biblically acceptable. Just as clearly, however, using brutish excessive force, striking in raw anger instead of in calm instruction, or repeating a pattern of physical roughshod over a child are definitely NOT what Jesus taught, and anyone who has read any of His teachings should know this as well. The point behind the proverb was that if you let your children be disobedient without consequences, you are hurting their social development (and their sense of right and wrong)in the long run. Young children (who still have only a limited understanding of cause and effect) respond best to a carefully administered moment of discomfort as a consequence of serious disobedience. If my toddler ran out into the street in front of a car after I had told him not to, you had better believe I would impress on him the serious danger he was in with sharp scold and a bottom smack to remember it with; My love for him and not wanting him to dismiss the incident as frivolous, rightly demands that I impress it on him in a way he's sure to learn from, and hopefully live longer because of. Do people abuse this? Sadly, of course they often do. I'm defending only the biblical principle, not the imperfect ways that some people might misguidedly choose to apply it. Just like any law, rule, or guidline, when it is applied without forethought and wisdom, it can undermine its own purpose and be detrimental to all involved. My prayers go out to you for wisdom for you and your neighbors. --

)

AusPoet

3:47PM | Wed, 13 October 2004

Thank you all for your thoughts on this. Basedon how John describes most things, I believe that he likely copied his father's words verbatim. And he did tell me that his mother says his father shouldn't hit the children, so that's a good thing. I will wait and see if anything else arises.


0 89 0

00
Days
:
11
Hrs
:
00
Mins
:
02
Secs
Premier Release Product
Eowyn Sci-fi for Dawn2
3D Figure Assets
Sale Item
$14.95 USD 40% Off
$8.97 USD

Privacy Notice

This site uses cookies to deliver the best experience. Our own cookies make user accounts and other features possible. Third-party cookies are used to display relevant ads and to analyze how Renderosity is used. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understood our Terms of Service, including our Cookie Policy and our Privacy Policy.