Renderosity Forums / Poser - OFFICIAL
Welcome to the Poser - OFFICIAL Forum
Forum Coordinators: RedPhantom
Poser - OFFICIAL F.A.Q (Last Updated: 2024 Nov 13 11:02 am)
Subject: Want critiques?
Is someone is on your favorite artists list, don't you get notifications regardless of which gallery they post in? That's a question, I've never received a notification from the WIP gallery. But if that is the case, can't we just use the Work in Progress gallery that already exists?
jpiazzo, got you added.
DarkPascual, do you want to join?
kalon, yes, you will get an ebot for any upload, so you can post in whatever gallery/genre you wish.
RandC, you can post in the WIP genre. I talked about the idea of a WIP or Critique gallery back on page... 4 I think.
"you are terrifying
and strange and beautiful
something not everyone knows how to love." - Warsan
Shire
I have a sugestion but I'm not sure if it's possible to do. When we get an ebot that a picture from a favourite artist has been posted, the ideal would be that the mail text it would contain the comment that we make when we add an artist as a favourite. I say this because I see that most people here already put a comment like "critique group" in this ocasion. When we receive an ebot it would help to know if that artist is from this group or not, in order not to take the risk to critique someone that doesn't belong to the group. I, at least, have several other favourite artists than the ones in this group and it's getting hard to know when to critique or not.
Just want to say I just pulled the image I posted tonight, Why?? Because the critique I received from this group on it was fantastic and I'm going to re-work it and re-post hopefully a better version.
Thanx to those that had the time to view and critique, much obliged, I'm gonna enjoy this!!!!
Injustice will be avenged.
Cofiwch Dryweryn.
One of the reasons English is so popular throughout the world is that it can be really screwed up and still underdstandable (lol).
You're English is fine DarkPasual.
<strong>bandolin</strong><br />
[Former 3DS Max forum coordinator]<br />
<br />
<a href="http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.php">Homepage</a> ||
<a href="http://www.renderosity.com/mod/sitemail/">SiteMail</a> ||
<a href="http://excalibur.renderosity.com/mod/gallery/browse.php?user_id=70375">
Gallery</a> || <a href="http://www.renderosity.com/mod/freestuff/index.php?username=bandolin">
Freestuff</a>
<p><em>Caution: just a hobbyist</em></p>
There is already a WIP gallery... If you care to modify and re-post an image based on feedback, it may be the most straightforward to do it the way TheFixer suggests, because if you update an existing image I don't believe new ebots are sent out. It would also be nice to start from a clean slate of comments, because hopefully at least some of them will no longer apply.
I like the way Deecey handled the revision to her image, I was wondering about the best way to go about it without losing the information gained.
Unfortunately, you can't comment on an image twice. So, if you're reading this Deecey, the image just totally glows now. Great adjustment!
Yes, this can work. I just got good feedback from Tiara, SoCalRoberta and Cobaltdream.
I posted a fixed version 'cause I still had my project file, the fixes were relatively easy, and most of all because the crits were right on the money.
On adding "critique group" or something to comments: I kind of think it would be cool if such comments were given "casually," as if they were the normal thing. By giving a good critique, you are in a sense identifying yourself as part of the group -- no preface necessary. But this is surely no big deal, anything you wish to write that is helpful is certainly OK by me.
On the other hand, if people felt more free around here to offer critiques -- and see it done right, and accepted graciously -- they might just start criquing without bothering to formally sign up in the thread. And then the Group would have to be considered a smashing success, yes?
Sign me up! Wheeeeeeeeeeeee!
As far as the re-posting fixed--if it's a simple fix, or something I SHOULD have in it, I'll go "D'OHHHHHHH!" and fix it. If it's some ungodly complicated thing to fix, I'll probably try not to let it happen again.
I want to grow as an artist, and this sounds like a way to do it. This hobby is SO complicated, everyone can learn something new! I KNOW I can. :lol:
I cannot save the world. Only my little piece of it. If we all act
together, we can save the world.--Nelson Mandela
An inconsistent hobgoblin is
the fool of little minds
Taking "Just do it" to a whole new level!
LOL, watch your ebot links, I just followed a link this morning to Bar-codes image but got someone elses, I didn't notice until after I posted. They are probably wondering why some strange person is leaving technical tips LOL
The best & most beautiful
things in the world cannot be seen nor touched... but felt in the
heart.
Helen Keller
My
Gallery
My
Freebies
My
Store
Chippsyann, DarkPascual and JoelGLaine, got you guys added.
Rutra - good idea - you want to post that in the suggestions forum?
"you are terrifying
and strange and beautiful
something not everyone knows how to love." - Warsan
Shire
I want to join too! Will be glad to learn what i do wrong, and off course what i do right...! lol
OK Vince, you're in :-)
Can I just remind everyone joining now that you need to add to favourites the artists on the list in the first post of this thread. Otherwise you won't get notifications when they upload! (alternatively, you can check everybody's gallery every day, but that could be quite time-consuming.)
"you are terrifying
and strange and beautiful
something not everyone knows how to love." - Warsan
Shire
We just blew out the art charts LOL look at the favourite artists list - whoops
The best & most beautiful
things in the world cannot be seen nor touched... but felt in the
heart.
Helen Keller
My
Gallery
My
Freebies
My
Store
I bet we have to come back time to time on page 1 to see if another name has appeared in order to add it on our fav list...
Quote - I have a sugestion but I'm not sure if it's possible to do. When we get an ebot that a picture from a favourite artist has been posted, the ideal would be that the mail text it would contain the comment that we make when we add an artist as a favourite. I say this because I see that most people here already put a comment like "critique group" in this ocasion. When we receive an ebot it would help to know if that artist is from this group or not, in order not to take the risk to critique someone that doesn't belong to the group. I, at least, have several other favourite artists than the ones in this group and it's getting hard to know when to critique or not.
I feel your pain!
I had someone add me to their favourites the other day but there was no "critique group" comment in the add. I don't know if they are part of the critque or just added me to their favourites, LOL
"It is good to see ourselves as
others see us. Try as we may, we are never
able to know ourselves fully as we
are, especially the evil side of us.
This we can do only if we are not
angry with our critics but will take in good
heart whatever they might have to
say." - Ghandi
vince - i would love for people to critique my past works. i'm going to be trying to critique some past works. right now i'm just keeping up with the usual weekend rush, but since you've asked i'll try to hit some of your gallery.
oh, and your welcome! to linkdink and rutra. i'm glad you can get something out of my comments. as a general note, i know my comments are verbose and hit quite a few points. this doesn't mean i take myself very seriously. take what you can use and leave what you can't. and i'm really enjoying looking at everyone's work. this is some great stuff.
as for the artcharts... well, it can't be doing but so much. the only people who have added me to their favorites have been other group members!
oh, and i just want to say this. someone mentioned in the other thread that this is an arbitrary and artificial way to get comments. for me it's not. i would rather have detailed critiques, and i would rather give them. i find myself taking much longer to write two or three purely positive lines that are also meaningful. i just don't do, "love it! it's perfect!" in general. it's not me. but a lot of people don't want thorough critiques, and for various highly respectable reasons. this group identifies matches me up with the kind of people i want to comment on, and who i want comments from. otherwise, i won't comment much. asking for thorough critiques is the natural way to get me to comment, not doing enticing thumbnails or posting technically perfect work.
Quote - Dear Acadia,
This is a notification that you made it onto this week's Art Charts at Renderosity.com, ranking 4th on the list of favorite artists! Furthermore, because you were a favorite artist, we featured "Ashley", which seems to be your most popular image to-date.
You can view the Art Charts by clicking here.
I'm somebody!!!! 
I have to go and look at "Ashley" because I honestly can't recall what that image looks like.
"It is good to see ourselves as
others see us. Try as we may, we are never
able to know ourselves fully as we
are, especially the evil side of us.
This we can do only if we are not
angry with our critics but will take in good
heart whatever they might have to
say." - Ghandi
I think it's hilarious!
What makes it funny is alot of the "unknowns" are really talented artists and just didn't have the network of friends to get recognized as such in the galleries.
I think it's great and I hope it opens people's eyes to the true meaning of the galleries...to display ART, not win a popularity contest!
well, i'm sure some will see this as a popularity issue. but i notice we're not anywhere else. we haven't taken over highest ranked or even most commented. and i suspect the art chart effect will die off once this gets steady. we each had lots of people add us at once. i'd be very surprised if the art charts were time independent.
Well, seeing as there aren't any cash prizes or worldwide fame at stake - I think it's just kind of humorous. I imagine in a week or two the chart will settle down a bit. Too funny.
:lol:
I think its a great thing! I'm sure after a few weeks it'll settle down and go back to relatively normal but the major bonus we'll get is now people will see our names and maybe view some of our stuff, see that we're getting a large amount of critical comments and maybe, just maybe they'll be brave enough to go about it on their own. That was the general idea behind this group correct?
I've always wanted more critical comments on my images, this group was a small way of guaranteeing that (did I just invent another word again?) So with us completely taking over the favorite artists chart at least for this week, we'll possibly get more views from people who would never have heard of us!
So cheers to everyone, its good to see we're making a difference! :D
We have 'Art-charts'? What's art-charts? Been here since 2003 or around that and still find new things all the time. :lol:
I'm an unknown, but I don't think I'm a great artist. I'm working on it. Maybe one day.
Besides--screw fame! I want MONEY!!!! ^__^ V,,
I cannot save the world. Only my little piece of it. If we all act
together, we can save the world.--Nelson Mandela
An inconsistent hobgoblin is
the fool of little minds
Taking "Just do it" to a whole new level!
Quote - ...Then when you get the money, you get the power. Then when you get the power, then you get the woman.:laugh:
Is that negotiable? Because I'd prefer a man :lol:
"you are terrifying
and strange and beautiful
something not everyone knows how to love." - Warsan
Shire
Well, we're at 52 names. You know a good idea when something is successful when it becomes a logistical nightmare.
I can no long distinguish between my regular faves and my critique group. Whenever someone posts a new image that I have as a fave I have to run back here to make sure they're on the list.
Also, I'd like to be able to subcatogorize my critique group artists. There are artists that I simply can't critique because I'm not familiar with the genre they're representing. Also I've notice some people are using other apps other than Poser. I'm fine with that, but I can't really critique on a technical issue when someone is using Vue. I've never used Vue. Similarly, I frequently use Max. That's why I'd like to catagorize the faves into subfolders.
<strong>bandolin</strong><br />
[Former 3DS Max forum coordinator]<br />
<br />
<a href="http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.php">Homepage</a> ||
<a href="http://www.renderosity.com/mod/sitemail/">SiteMail</a> ||
<a href="http://excalibur.renderosity.com/mod/gallery/browse.php?user_id=70375">
Gallery</a> || <a href="http://www.renderosity.com/mod/freestuff/index.php?username=bandolin">
Freestuff</a>
<p><em>Caution: just a hobbyist</em></p>Let me be blunt--THE APP DOESN'T REALLY MATTER!
If someone uses Poser exclusively, then It might. Almost everyone uses a combo of apps, nowadays.
The real point is to figure out what looks good, what looks off, or wrong and making helpful comments to correct any gaffs or stumbles. If they are apps used, that you know--be as pointed about the fine points as you want.
Simple stuff like someone's eyes being pointed in different directions, we ALL know what's wrong. :lol:
I cannot save the world. Only my little piece of it. If we all act
together, we can save the world.--Nelson Mandela
An inconsistent hobgoblin is
the fool of little minds
Taking "Just do it" to a whole new level!
Privacy Notice
This site uses cookies to deliver the best experience. Our own cookies make user accounts and other features possible. Third-party cookies are used to display relevant ads and to analyze how Renderosity is used. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understood our Terms of Service, including our Cookie Policy and our Privacy Policy.
i can say i don't expect others to change their images, nor am i likely to change mine. just because i can see some weak points, doesn't mean i think the picture should be reworked. i'm not giving feedback so that anyone can change anything. i think of course everyone should do what they want, but i just don't think people should feel they have to make corrections based on critiques. just my 2 cents...