Tue, Nov 26, 7:20 PM CST

Renderosity Forums / Complaint & Debate



Welcome to the Complaint & Debate Forum

(Last Updated: 2024 Aug 27 11:07 am)

Please read the article on the front page regarding the closing of C&D.


Subject: Call For Action In The Poser Community


  • 1
  • 2
kjlintner ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 9:10 PM · edited Tue, 26 November 2024 at 7:13 PM

Attached Link: The Banning of George Deep from the PFO

I am sure that most of you have read the beautiful article written by George Deep on the tragedy that occured in NYC today. I was wondering how many of you know that George was banned from from the PFO for making the post, which was deleted. I am speechless. One man pleads for unification and peace in the community, and another man spits in his face, and basically spits on each one of us, our electronic community and on our country. I am writing a letter to Egi.sys and to Daz3D and will include the same link that I am placing below. I will then request that egi.sys stop hosting the PFO and that Daz3D stop hosting their free stuff. Is anyone else with me? You may think I am overreacting, but any one you who had to explain what happend today to your children should understand. My son is 8. He teeters between belief in disbelief over the childhood joys of Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny. He wants to believe but then again, it seems so illogical. When I sat him down to explain what had happend (the school basically told him that there was a bad plane crash and that recess was cancelled), I saw something shift in his face, something dim from his eyes. Welcome to the real world, my little man, my best friend in life. Maybe I am over-reacting, but I have a right to do so


LordsWarrior ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 9:25 PM

YEAH..reading that...that was pretty lame of them {:O( -LW


DgerzeeBoy ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 10:12 PM

The people who run the PFO are--and always have been--two dull-brained pendants. Their site isn't much of a resource for anything but their own silly posturing. Although they may wave the banner of egi.systems, believing it gives them some legitimacy or importance, they're not even much a blip on the community screen, pretty much relegating themselves (and deservedly so), to the status of an afterthought.


LordsWarrior ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 11:05 PM

I dont think its really necessary to ask DAZ and whoever to dismiss the PFO. But if people are angered by what they have done, then they probably will not visit again. That in itself with be punishment...as without visitors websites dont survive. -LW


Dreamspinner ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 11:15 PM

This is Liz Pope, writing for both Verdie Ingram and myself, this tragedy is almost beyond belief! You're letter was wonderful and I agree that in a time like this that the whole community should pull together. We are an artists community comprised of so many people from different countries and cultures with one thing in common, the creation of beautiful 3d art. Are hopes and prayers go to those most directly affected by today's events. And I am absolutely astonished that the PFO would ban you George for sentiments of community support, believing instead that you were seeking monetary gain for it! I just can't believe something so stupid. Liz Pope and Verdie Ingram Dreamspinner Inc.


kjlintner ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 11:20 PM

But they survive a lot longer when they have a free ride.


nikitacreed ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 11:25 PM

Content Advisory! This message contains violence

What I can't believe is that ANYONE would try and turn such a wonderfully written post about "community" and pertaining so eloquently to the current crisis in America right now...into a petty little slam against Renderosity. Thank you for your wonderful post George. It was beautiful. Forgive my language....but the PFO can go fuck themselves. That's all I have to say in the matter. Bastards.


nikitacreed ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 11:26 PM

Meaning behind the above over-emotional post: Consider my letter to DAZ and Egi.sys written.


shadowcat ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 11:28 PM

God forbid you mention another website.... the horror... how could he possibly do that.... Can you hear the sarcasam?


dcort ( ) posted Tue, 11 September 2001 at 11:58 PM

Maybe we should all ban the PFO. Don't go there anymore. I don't usually say anything bad about anyone, but in this case the PFO's actions are utterly distasteful. This is gross and disgusting behavior. I would strongly urge DAZ and egi to withdraw their hosting and support of the PFO. Narrow-minded individuals who can't give up their personal vendettas even on a tragic day like today don't deserve community support. If anything, today's events should serve to remind us all that there are more important things than Poser.


kjlintner ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 12:03 AM

Attached Link: http://www.3dcommune.com/3d/forum.mv?Announcements_News+read+8999768987

I would like to ask you all to click on the link above and post your support for George by demanding that Grey restore George's account on the PFO and allow his post to be restored. I think if enough people spoke up, UNIFIED, that something good will indeed come out of this. Please click on the link below and add your post.


BECamation ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 12:15 AM

Hi folks. This is A1HostCoMark from the Commune. I know you never see me post here. :^) I also wanted to ask you to please do the right thing here and not lash out at Ian for what he did. I'm not defending him or what happened but I personally think that in light of what happened today that we all try to do the right thing and start somewhere. I was the one asking for the community to ask Ian nicely to reinstate George's status at the PFO. Banning the PFO or boycotting it or asking EGI to not host him anymore or whatever isn't the solution. The solution is to band together for once towards a common goal. Between all of our sites we are a powerful voice. Let your voice be heard as bearers of good will. Thank you. Mark


kjlintner ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 12:24 AM

I agree Mark, we need to stand together as an electronic community and show our support for George. I am still going ahead with my letter writing campaign to Egi.sys and Daz.3d. George attempted to bring the community together as a show of our support for the victims of yesterday's horrific events. Ian chose to serve his own agendas, again and thumbed his nose at all of us. He needs to go.


GeorgeD ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 12:32 AM

Please. This is getting way out of hand. I do thank you for all your interest and support in this matter but honestly this is not what I want or expected. Up until my post at the PFO today I haven't been there in nearly 8 months to a year. I just wanted to post my letter for all to read and reflect on. If Grey feels the need to say what he did to me in his emails fine. He wants to ban me fine. I just don't think his attitude towards what I was saying in my original post was funny. He for some reason has held a grudge with Renderosity and anyone who has anything to do with the site. His problem..whatever it may be..is between himself and someone other than me. To take his hatred out on me was uncalled for. Even if he does unban me I won't be going back. I have found true friends at Renderosity and here. I'm happy with that. GeorgeD


Nance ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 1:09 AM

Let it go folks. Please, we've all had enough hatred for one day.


nitreug ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 1:51 AM

I thought that people are banned for using files that are not them. Now it looks that people can be banned for opinions. that does make no sence at all!!!


Nance ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 2:12 AM

sigh...


LordsWarrior ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 3:29 AM

Nit, It is their site..they can ban whoever..but they do have to ( and will) live with the results of it. The looks of it is they have banned a popular Rendo/PropsGuild member and may now have lost support from alot of other Rendo members. It does not help the matter to goto arms against the PFO for this. GD has asked for the matter to be let go...so we should respect his wishes. The banning event has damaged the PFO's reputation already already it seems, there is no need to try and puh it any further. I am not in any means trying to defend them, and..I probably wont visit myself, but trying to destroy their reputation with DAZ and where ever does not help things. We're a community of artists...not a lynch mob. -LW


nerd ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 4:09 AM
Forum Moderator

I've been kicked out of better places than that. They booted me over a year ago when I started selling my stuff. And I NEVER promoted my stuff there, only posted my free stuff. They said I was a commercial interest and not welcome. I guess they think I'm a capitolist pig. I find being able to pay the mortgage VERY inspiring. It is fitting they would boot someone bearing an olive branch. What a bunch of sh*t heads. I haven't been there in ages and will never return.


praxis22 ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 6:02 AM

Well that's fairly surreal :) I know the man hates this place, but that takes the biscuit. "I hold in my hand a piece of paper..." (which will make sense to the Brits in the audience) later jb


futuramik ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 6:05 AM

I'm with nitacreed ,they will not see me visit there site again


Anthony Appleyard ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 6:07 AM

At the end of George Deep's message, he put a WWW address of a .JPG file with his "In Remembrance 09-11-01" banner in. That WWW address was on Renderosity's site. And PFO did not like that. God alone knows why, at this of all times.


neurocyber ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 6:37 AM

Breaking the hand that bears the Olive branch is behavior that is not Civil. News of PFO doing this again realy saddens me.


ookami ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 6:53 AM

(Putting finger and thumb by forehead in the shape of an "L") L-O-S-E-R What the heck?! What kind of petty low life loser bands someone for posting such a profound statement after such an incredible tradegy?! Get over yourselves PFO! Personally, that type of indescriminate banning does justify us asking to have their site taken down. Some people might mistakenly believe that PFO represents our Community and personally, I don't want that type of pettiness representing the Poser community. I'd rather let it be said that we are a collection of artists with sympathy, dignity and compassion.


Ironbear ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 7:17 AM

I'm with Pariah and Nikita.

"I am a good person now and it feels... well, pretty much the same as I felt before (except that the headaches have gone away now that I'm not wearing control top pantyhose on my head anymore)"

  • Monkeysmell


Cheryle ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 8:14 AM

wow totally tasteless tacky and insensitive of the pfo. I don't know the history, nor do i want to know the history, but this is out of line. "Personally, that type of indescriminate banning does justify us asking to have their site taken down. Some people might mistakenly believe that PFO represents our Community and personally, I don't want that type of pettiness representing the Poser community.".. ookami well said, i agree.


Jackson ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:10 AM

Can someone please tell me who or what PFO is? Thanks in advance.


MGCJerry ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:15 AM

Content Advisory! This message contains violence

The PFO doesn't like anything with the name "renderosity" in it. The PFO does not use HTML in their forums. I'M NOT DEFENDING THE PFO!!! This is fucking bullshit. I have visited there the last time to remove my freestuff and previous posts...


Ironbear ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:16 AM

It's "Poser Forum Online", and EGI/CL sponsored poser community forum. Predecessor to this one. I'm not going to post the url... but I'm sure someone can get you one.

"I am a good person now and it feels... well, pretty much the same as I felt before (except that the headaches have gone away now that I'm not wearing control top pantyhose on my head anymore)"

  • Monkeysmell


ArchAngelofHell ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:16 AM

Man thats fuckign bull shit. PFO has gone to far fpor banning you for that. but since you wish us not to take it any further i will respect your wishs and not do anything. But pfo shouldn't be allowed to be up and with the surpport they get. AAH


Anthony Appleyard ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:24 AM

It is the Poser Forum Online. It is a group somewhat like Renderosity. It seems to have a few hundred downloadable objects etc. It and Renderosity split from each other in one of the schisms that has happened in the past. Is it possible that this ban was not a human decision but automatic? Perhaps their software has a "detect offensive word" system and they put "renderosity" in the list of forbidden words.


MGCJerry ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:27 AM

the Admins ban people from the PFO. My friend NightHawk (aka. ArchAngel) has mentioned "Renderosty" and has not gotten banned YET. He is verbally attacking the PFO as I post here. I have removed my freestuff from the pfo.


Jackson ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:34 AM

Thanks, Ironbear. I was just curious what is was, I don't want the URL.


kjlintner ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:35 AM

"Is it possible that this ban was not a human decision but automatic? Perhaps their software has a "detect offensive word" system and they put "renderosity" in the list of forbidden words." I seriously doubt it. Ian patrols those forii with an almost religious fervor just waiting for someone to say something that goes against his way of thinking. I have reread George's request many times. I see him asking to discontinue the campaign to get his account restored on PFO. I am going to continue the write in effort to request EGI and DAZ stop their support of the PFO. I am doing this is all person's best interests. My grandmother always told me "you are known by the company you keep." Egi.sys and Daz3D are keeping some pretty bad company with Grey and the PFO right now. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------


ArchAngelofHell ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:45 AM

i agree write those letters to them and get them to stop and give me the address to and i will write them too.


Styxx ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 10:14 AM

The actions of the PFO are horrendous. I am not one to point fingers around here, but in this I cannot remain silent... Their actions at this time are... putred! I am deeply hurt by their arrogent attitudes and paranoid delusions! I've said enough :( Styxx


TJ ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 10:19 AM

As Ive always said. Its a sad place there, and a shame that the software makers support a site where 9 out of 10 poser users will never feel welcome.


ronstuff ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 10:59 AM

Attached Link: http://www.maleposer.com/cgi-bin/poserboard/forums.cgi?forum=4

For those of you interested in contributing to a global discussion on the recent tragedies, I have created a forum on MalePoser to address these issues. As horrible as this tragedy is, I do not believe that it is over... it has just begun. I am currently at ground zero, and am very concerned about what the media is NOT saying. Use the link above to go the forum where I will be posting eperiodic updates from Manhattan.


Stormrage ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 12:38 PM

Situation normal at the PFO.. nuff said.. George.. thank you for the wonderful post.. You said it so well and i agree with all you said. Forget the PFO.. They don't matter anymore.. I will lodge my complaint with Daz and 3D in support..


Helen ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 1:04 PM

I have sat on the fence with the PFO issue.. Thought its their site, each to their own.. etc etc Could never understand their non-commericial use policy.. Kinda like telling a plumber you can buy a wrench, but don't you dare use it except for personal home repairs... BUT this goes too far.. Just for the record.. Anything sold via Renderosity for the Community Fund is 100% given to the fund.. NO payments to the vendors, NO percentage taken by Renderosity.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Senior MarketPlace Tester

If anyone sees a mind wandering aimlessly around..... It is mine.  I want it back.



x2000 ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 1:22 PM

Hmm. The PFO folks hate us because we're members of Renderosity. Kind of like how these terrorists hate us because we're Americans...? Sigh Hasn't anyone learned ANYTHING from what happened yesterday? I support a ban wholeheartedly, at least until they see the light, apologize, and end this stupid obsession with Renderosity. Anyone with such ignorant biases should be held accountable for them. I don't care what their gripe is with this site, they should not be taking it out on our members. Maybe when nine-tenths of their members leave, they'll re-think their policies? On the other hand, if no one takes a stand, then nothing will ever change. But no flame wars, please. That just causes more anger. We've had enough of that, haven't we? If you want to support this, just don't go there anymore. If Ian gets lonely, let HIM come HERE and apologize. Until then, I for one am going to avoid the PFO like a dead skunk on the highway.


Crescent ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 2:54 PM

If I may remind people: THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE DIED YESTERDAY! This is bullshit under the bridge. Leave it there.


kjlintner ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 3:09 PM

"If I may remind people: THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE DIED YESTERDAY!" That is correct and one flaming asshole and his partner-in-slime have thumbed their noses at it and deemed their fund-raising activities the only ones that are worthy.


x2000 ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 3:10 PM

Yes, they did. But as cold as it may sound, life goes on. Should we ignore every insult because thousands of people died yesterday? As far as I'm concerned, it just makes me more determined to fight this sort of thing. Life is too short to spend it being insulted and abused by morons like the PFO. What's more, that is exactly what the terrorists wanted: to cripple us, demoralize us, to stop us in our tracks. And I for one will be DAMNED if I'm going to give the bastards the satisfaction. You want to curl up in a ball and wimper, fine. But I don't think most Americans are going to give up that easily. Life goes on, and by God it SHOULD! Forget bombs and tanks: you want to fight them? Just keep living your life, same as always. That IS what they hate us for, right? That IS what they were trying to stop? They've stolen enough lives. They're NOT getting mine.


Roy G ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 3:23 PM

In trying to keep an open mind. And I wanted to hear both sides of this issue. I visited the PFO and found where Willow had this to say. "Any members coming here to promote fund raising of an obvious self serving purpose will be banned and NEVER allowed back. You want to help - Make the check payable to Red Cross. I am disgusted at those wanting to make a profit from this tragedy. This is not open for discussion, I will close this statement - grief earns a far different direction then this." So it appears that Willow is also a flaming ass hole. I would consider it an honor too be banned from that place. I won't be going back again, EVER!


kjlintner ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 5:54 PM

I think x2000 has said it best. Thanks for your understanding and support.


leather-guy ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 6:17 PM
Online Now!

Attached Link: http://www.fool.com/news/2001/list010912.htm

Also on a positive note re: the tragedy. this page has gathered a lot of links to sites that offer ways to help in the aftermath. http://www.fool.com/news/2001/list010912.htm


ScottA ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 6:24 PM

Sorry folks. I feel I must move this thread to the C&D forum. It's really getting nasty and doesn't deal with Poser. I have been on Grey and Willow's *hit list for longer than almost anyone here. So I agree with their acts being business as usual (insert profanity here). But I am sworn to uphold the policies of this site. And that means keeping rants about other people (no matter how deserving they are) in the proper forum. I hope you all understand. And don't think I'm defending them. Because I'm not. ScottA


kjlintner ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 7:21 PM

No offense taken, Scott. I posted it here because it dealt with a snub to the Poser community. This latest embarrasment comes from someone who enjoys portraying himself in a light that he is some sort of personal spokesman for Kupa, CL, Daz, and Egi.sys. Moving it to C&D is quite fine, the more who get to read it, the merrier. :)


CharlieBrown ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 7:45 PM

People, I cannot CONDONE what the PFO did - I think it was reprehensible - but I can UNDERSTAND it. Grey is as rabidly anti-EdgeNet and anything concerning it as the terrorists are anti-American and anything concerning IT. He overreacted, something he is VERY prone to do, and is being chastised for it. That should be enough - there is enough tragedy out there that we need no petty stone throwing here! If George weren't a MODERATOR here, I believe he would have just gotten a warning, BTW - as I did once, for trying to help someone find something they were looking for there, but he's part of "the establishment," and thus "unforgiveable." I don't agree with their decision, but can understand why they made it. Tasteless and dumb though it may be, the PFO IS their site, and they DO have the right to ban whomever they want for whatever reason.


kjlintner ( ) posted Wed, 12 September 2001 at 9:48 PM

But what happens when there's no one left to ban? Ian and Willow, smug as can be, proud of themselves for ridding the PFO of all of the unimportant (in their opinion) people in the world will sit on their imaginary thrones and pat themselves on the back on a job well done. I think Daz and CL need to pay attention. Consumers are angry. I have heard talks of boycotts.


  • 1
  • 2

Privacy Notice

This site uses cookies to deliver the best experience. Our own cookies make user accounts and other features possible. Third-party cookies are used to display relevant ads and to analyze how Renderosity is used. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understood our Terms of Service, including our Cookie Policy and our Privacy Policy.